Harvard HBS 2010 MBA Application Questions, Deadlines, Tips.

UPDATE- THE TIPS FOR HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL’S 2011 MBA APPLICATION ARE NOW ONLINE. Please post questions or comments to the new post.

 

Harvard HBS 2010 MBA Application Deadlines

Round Due Date Notification
Round 1 October 1, 2009* December 15, 2009
Round 2 January 19, 2010* April 6, 2010
Round 3 April 8, 2010* May 13, 2010
* Applications are due by 5:00 PM EST

Harvard HBS 2010 MBA Essay Questions

My comments are in red:

As an opportunity to present your distinctive qualities, your essays are an important part of your MBA application. You will be asked to submit your personal statements online with the balance of your application materials. Essays should be single-spaced. Please limit your response to the length indicated.

All applicants must submit answers to four essay questions. The first two questions are required of all applicants. The remaining two essays should be in response to your choice of the next five sub-questions.

Joint program applicants for the Harvard Medical School, Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Harvard Law School, and Harvard Kennedy School must provide an additional essay.

ESSAYS:

Essay 1- What are your three most substantial accomplishments and why do you view them as such? (600-word limit)

This is practically Harvard‘s signature question. It has been around for years, and it goes to the heart of Harvard’s values. It wants highly accomplished students entering its program. It wants leaders.

At least one and probably two of the three accomplishments should show leadership and/or teamwork with the emphasis being on leadership. I also like to have this essay show some breadth. My ideal would be to have one professional, one community, and one personal accomplishment in this essay, but that breakdown is neither set in stone nor imperative.

Essay 2- What have you learned from a mistake? (400-word limit)

People of initiative err. They must learn from those mistakes to be effective leaders.

A friend went to her daughter’s graduation and quoted the valedictory address, “In school you learn lessons and then take tests. In life, you have tests and then learn lessons.” If you view your mistakes as experiments, lessons, or tests, you can grow and make sure you don’t repeat them. Show HBS through this essay that you are the kind of person who learns from your mistakes.

Again, try to have this question reveal you making your mistake, preferably in a leadership capacity, and applying lessons learned in a sphere of your life not covered by other essays. In the best HBS applications, each essay uncovers a different facet of the applicant and his or her experience. Together they paint a portrait of a dynamic, talented leader with initiative and exceptional ability. 

Essay 3-Please respond to two of the following (400-word limit each):

1- What would you like the MBA Admissions Board to know about your undergraduate academic experience?

This question was originally mandatory, but has been optional for the last 2 years. When introduced, I thought it was going to produce monotonous, boring essays, but it didn’t. To my pleasant surprise, I reviewed several of these essays as part of our quality control program, and they were revealing, excellent essays.

This question reflects Harvard’s interest in early career applicants and really gives them a chance to shine. This essay represents HBS’ attempt to see patterns over time. What you choose to include here will obviously vary depending on your experience and the rest of your application, but my ideal answer will discuss a leadership experience from your undergrad career to show that you are a natural leader with a history of leadership. Remember: HBS wants to develop leaders, not create them.

2- Discuss how you have engaged with a community or organization.

As you answer this question, once again keep in mind Harvard’s single-minded focus on leadership. Did you motivate, inspire, plan, or organize? If you did, what were the results of your actions? Did you increase revenue? membership? communal impact? “Community or organization” is very broad so you could answer this question and relate it to work, but most of you will want to answer this question with non-professional initiatives in your community.

3- Tell us about a time when you made a difficult decision.

New Question. Difficult decisions: Those where all outcomes carry significant negatives. Those with potential  major risks and rewards. And above all, those shrouded in uncertainty and ambiguity.

What was your difficult decision? How did you weigh the different factors and come to a conclusions? What were the risks? What were the results? 

4- Write a cover letter to your application introducing yourself to the Admissions Board.

New Question. Like all cover letters, this is a sales document. Make your case for admission highlighting the aspects of your background that show impact and fit with Harvard. How do your talents and accomplishments demonstrate fit with the HBS, the give-and-take of the case method, and its focus on leadership and strategic thinking?

5-What is your career vision and why is this choice meaningful to you?

Harvard is one of the few top business schools that has made the goals question optional. And even this one is a little different than the typical “What do you want to do and why do you want to do it?”The interesting twist to Harvard’s question is “career vision.” With Harvard’s focus on strategy, Harvard is asking you to develop your career strategy and discuss its importance to you. But don’t leave your answer on an entirely theoretical plane. Bring it down to earth with your plan for implementing that vision. In other words writing that you seek “a career leading an innovative enterprise, providing work-life balance, and allowing me the opportunity to contribute to my community” sounds great. But it will also sound a lot like other people’s visions. You need to have some idea of how to achieve that vision, define it more narrowly, and explain why it resonates with you.

For more on the concept of vision, please see “The Parable of the Three Stone Masons.” I believe that HBS is attempting to identify those who are like the third stonemason — perhaps with less religious fervor but with well… that kind of vision. They are still working hard, with feet on the ground, but they radiate enthusiasm for a distant goal and pride in their ability to contribute to something much larger than themselves.

If you would like help with your Harvard MBA application, please consider Accepted’s MBA essay editing and admissions consulting or a Harvard MBA Comprehensive Package, which includes essay editing, interview coaching, consultation, and a resume edit for the Harvard MBA application.

Other resources to help you with your Harvard Business School MBA application:

Final suggestion, actually from Dee Leopold, Director of Harvard’s MBA Admissions, watch the video Inside the HBS Case Method.

 

About Linda Abraham
  • Sandra Higgins

    If the early career candidates are the main targets of the "Undergraduate experience" essay, would it hurt for some one 5 years out of college to write about the same?

  • Linda Abraham

    Not automatically. However, you should weigh whether a more recent experience would say more about you and your leadership ability today than a story that is at least 5-6 years old.

    Best,
    Linda

  • American Porteno

    I am considering using the ‘Undergraduate Academic Experience’ essay as a platform to discuss, maybe justify the upward sloping line that is my college transcript. Due to my typical story of ‘rough start, strong finish’ (last semester was 1st time on dean’s list), I feel the need to ‘sell-myself’ as a product of continuous improvement. My overall undergrad was a mediocre 3.1 but my university only considered ones last 66 hours in regards to honors status, so in spite of the 3.1, I have a cum laude graduation status. What is your opinion on this? Is this completely NOT the content that HBS is looking for by offering this essay? Thanks.

  • Linda Abraham

    I would need to see the particulars to answer this question. I could see it being effective, and I could imagine it flopping entirely. However, if your overall GPA is 3.1 don’t set your heart on HBS. Chances are slim and the rest of your application will have to be stellar.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Abhishek

    Hi Linda,

    I work for a start up financial valuations company ( Was one of the first employees and helped setting up the company. In addition setup the healthcare strategy consulting practice of this firm. Have previously worked for Deloitte, Pwc, and E&Y.

    Did my undergrad from Canada (GPA 3.0). During undergrad started my own pharmacy retail chain to fund my education. As a result my attention was divided between university and my business.

    My aim is to get a MBA degree with a focus in healthcare initiative. Post which I want to come back to India and expand the pharmacy and hospital chain I partly own.

    My GMAT Score was 680.

    I just want to know whether I have any chances at HBS, some of the people i spoke to have asked me to not to apply to top 5.

    Abhishek

  • Linda Abraham

    I think your chances at HBS would be poor. Sorry. I pretty much agree that you should apply outside the top 10 or work to beef up the academic aspect of your profile. Alternatively, check out EMBA programs because I sense that you are an older applicant and experience counts more in EMBA admissions.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Anon

    1. GMAT – On 29 Sep 2009
    2. Serving Indian Army Officer (Captain)
    3. Age 29
    4. Sex – Female
    5. Bachelor of Science / PG diploma in Computer Science
    6. 06 yrs of hard first hand experience in Supply Chain Management in all theatres including siachen glacier and Kashmir, Ladakh region
    7. Consistent and documented track record of academic and professional excellence. Two best student awards in career courses in indian army.
    8. Mountaineer, Trekker, won many prizes in Sports
    9. Areas of interest : banking and Microfinance.
    10. member of Army adventure wing
    11. Associated with 2 welfare organisations
    Will this profile interest HBS?

    thanks

  • Linda Abraham

    Without a GPA or GMAT, it is very hard to say. I can say that HBS would find your military experience of interest.

    Best,
    Linda Abraham

  • Francois Blanc

    Hi Linda,
    Am european, 35 years old, M. As of now managing a large team of professionals (50+) at a large multinational in the financial services industry. Graduated Cum Laude from a very recognized european university, and have a 700 GMAT score. Have no "community service" and my extracurricular activities are very poor.
    Do you think that my age will be impacting my chances to get admitted?
    Thank you in advance for your advice.

  • Linda Abraham

    Francois,

    In a word "yes." Your age/high level of experience and your lack of extra-curriculars would both hurt you at Harvard. Look into top programs that are friendlier to older applicants. Also provide a clear goal that on one hand requires an MBA and on the other is realistic for someone who will be 37 or 38 upon graduation. If you expect to get an entry level investment banking or management consulting position, you may not be considered realistic. Please see http://www.accepted.com/mba/older.aspx .

    Also look into Sloan Fellows programs at Stanford, MIT, and LBS.

    Best,

  • Peter

    Hi Linda,

    First of all, I think it’s great that you take the time to help applicants in this forum and with your commercial services.

    I am planning to apply to HBS this year. I am a non-native English speaker from Germany. My GPA in Engineering is 4.0 from one of the top 5 European Engineering/Science schools, but my GMAT is only 730 (strangely with a low 80s percentile in quant, but a strong mid 90s in verbal). Should I retake it given that this year’s application process will be more competitive? I’ve heard that application numbers are up 40% due to the crisis. Will a 5.0 on the AWA hurt my application?

    Thanks and regards,

  • Linda Abraham

    You’re most welcome.

    The 5.0 AWA is not an issue at all.

    If your quant is over 80%, I would not retake, especially given all the other evidence of outstanding quantitative skills.

    I haven’t heard of any 40% increase in application numbers for almost a year. The adcom directors I have spoken to either expect a slight increase or flat application volume this year.

    Several schools have also emphasized that they are seeking European applicants.

    With good essays and interviews, I think you are in good shape.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Sid

    Hi Linda,
    Firstly, I think you are doing a great job in answering questions. It has helped me a lot.
    I am planning to apply to HBS this year and wanted to know whether my application has a shot.
    Academics:
    GPA: 3.83 Cum Laude, Phi Beta Kappa from a top 50 liberal arts school
    GMAT: 730
    On the board of many student clubs.
    Work Experience:
    1 year at a top strategy consulting firm in USA (had to quit because of visa issues)
    2 yrs at an Internet startup in Mumbai where I lead a team of 20.
    Other Experience:
    My father was a businessman and managed several companies. When I was 17 he passed away. Since then I have managed 4 family owned companies and have brought the family business out of bankruptcy and they are now profitable ventures.
    I have even started a charitable foundation in my fathers name that raises funds and distributes it to NGOs that treat depression patients (the cause of my fathers death).
    In addition I volunteer at a couple of NGOs in Mumbai.

    Do you think I have a decent shot at HBS? Also, in my essays should I stress on my family experience (losing my father, managing companies) or should I steer away from that and focus on other full time experiences (consulting and startup)? Or a mix of both?
    Look forward to your reply.
    Thanks,
    SS

  • Linda Abraham

    Sid,

    Yes you have a shot at HBS.
    You definitely should talk about managing your family’s businesses and the circumstances you found them in when you took them over as well as how successfully you grew them. How much you should write about it is something that I can’t answer on a message board based on a short post. You clearly have a lot of other experience you can and should talk about too. I just can’t give you a ratio based on the above info.

    Best,
    Linda

  • KC

    Does Harvard have an optional question that asks the applicant to explain any extenuating circumstances to the Committee? Thanks!

    KC

  • KC

    I recently founded a startup. Will this put me in the EMBA pile? Thanks!

    KC

  • mehmet

    international candidate from turkey
    Bs.Electrical and Electronics Eng. 2.52 4.0 last semester
    Msc.Engineering Management 4.00(got accounting statistics economics finance classes)
    Ucla accounting and Lse finance classes summer school all A and Gmat 790..2.5 years project manager in top defense company and lots of real leadership and venture capital company
    Do i have shot at hbs? My u.gpa is a problem?

  • mehmet

    my bs and ms universities are both top universities in turkey.and i really need real feedback about my poor gpa.big chances or little chances?
    Thanks in advance linda i am looking forward for your reply

  • Mike

    Hi Linda,

    I am planning to apply to HBS this year. I am from Ghana. My GPA in Systems Engineering is 3.5 from UVA, my GMAT is 710.I have 2 years IB at Morgan Stanley. I have a couple of leadership experiences from undergrad. what are my chances?

    Thanks,

    Mike Lawson

  • Linda Abraham

    KC,
    The presence or absence of an start-up on your resume does not determine if you are an appropriate candidate for an EMBA program. Most EMBA candidates are a little older/experienced than regular MBA candidates. Furthermore, they want a program that allows them to continue working. For more information, please see The EMBA Edge: A Guide to EMBA Admissions at http://www.accepted.com/Ecommerce/mba/EMBAEssay.aspx .

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Mike,

    Your credentials and African background should make you a very serious candidate at HBS. Don’t count on HBS, but definitely apply.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Your UGPA is a problem. But there is also a lot of mitigating data and you are very hard to comment on. I am not optimistic, because of the low GPA, but if you really want HBS, give it a try. Please see low GMAT/GPA at http://www.accepted.com/mba/lowstats.aspx .

    Best,
    Linda

  • mehmet

    linda is my low gpa also problem in lbs?with this profile my chances are high in london?

  • Linda Abraham

    Mehmet,

    A 2.52 GPA is a hurdle at all top programs. It is perhaps more possible to overcome at London Business School, but is is an issue. Again, you do have mitigating data so it is hard for me to be confident in my response. Please see the advise on the linked to page I provided and apply to more programs in the hope that a top program will look at the mitigating data, the explanation for the initial low grades, and your subsequent record of achievement and decide to accept.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Mike

    Hi Linda,

    I am planning to apply to HBS this year. I am from Ghana. My GPA in Systems Engineering is 3.5 from UVA, my GMAT is 710.I have 2 years IB at Morgan Stanley. I have a couple of leadership experiences from undergrad. what are my chances?

    Thanks,

    Mike Lawson

  • Zee

    Hi Linda,
    I am currently an undergrad student. I was wondering if HBS requires a work experience and if so what should be the minimum experience? Would a BE degree and a decent GMAT score be enough?

  • SS

    Hi Linda,
    Is there information available on which schools are known for which programs? Is there a process to decide on which MBA schools to apply to. I am looking to apply for an MBA this fall and have about 15 schools in mind (top 10 US MBA schools plus LBS, INSEAD and ISB). Given that it is only possible to apply to 4-5 schools, how does one decide which ones to narrow down from this list of 15.
    I would like to enter the real estate market as I own a large tract of land in Mumbai which I would like to develop into a special economic zone, partnering with a large commercial developer. I guess my question is which schools have the best real estate and entrepreneurship programs (out of the top 15 schools listed above) that could give me the best skills to go ahead with this large scale development project after my MBA.
    Thanks,
    SS

  • Poly

    Hello Linda,

    I need advice about how to proceed further with my grad school application. I’m an international 24-year-old female. I just got my GMAT today and i have 680.
    I’m aiming at HBS and MIT Sloan for an MBA in 2010. I would like to know if i have chances to be accepted with this gmat score or i should retake the exam. My profile is the following:
    Undergraduate GPA: 3.96
    double major- Business Administration and Economics from the American University in Bulgaria.
    I studied one semester at the University of Maine, GPA there 4.00
    By the time I start my master i will have 2 years of work experience in one of the multinational audit companies.
    I think i have good extra curricular activities – internship at a bank, Phi Beta Delta, student clubs and some volunteer work.
    Does this profile give me a chance at HBS or MIT?
    Thank you in advance for your advice.

  • Linda Abraham

    Mike,

    I replied on Aug 6 to your earlier post.

    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Zee,

    HBS does not require work experience. It actually has set up a special program (2+2) for college students who want an MBA. That said, it accepted only one applicant last year straight from college. Please see http://www.hbs.edu/mba/profiles/classprofile.html .

    In general, getting into HBS requires more than a "BE degree and a decent GMAT." It requires really a stellar record of achievement with a strong emphasis on leadership.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    SS.

    I went through this in some depth in "Best Practices for MBA Admissions" a webinar I gave in May. You can find it here: http://www.accepted.com/mba/applicationwebinar.aspx .

    Based on your post and assuming you have the qualifications for the top 15, focus your research on (in no particular order) UCLA, Chicago, Columbia, MIT Sloan, Stanford, Wharton, HBS, and LBS. Narrow from there.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Poly,

    What was the percentile breakdown of your GMAT?

  • Poly

    The percentile breakdown of my gmat is Quant 74 and Verbal 83.

  • Linda Abraham

    Poly,

    You certainly have a chance with your current score, however, I think your chance would probably be far better if you had a better GMAT score.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Jay

    Hi Linda,
    I don’t have a lot of professional experience – I immigrated by myself from a collapsing communist country when I was 18 and have worked odd jobs because of my immigration situation. After 3 years working in a family retail business I rose from a salesperson to distribution/inventory manager to general manager of 4 stores.Then I went to college where I managed to graduate with a BA in 3 semesters (1.5 years) – I took 18 CLEP tests. My GPA is 3.95. My GMAT is 750 and AWA score is 6.0. I have a couple of scholarships but was never active in clubs or organizations… I feel that I have great potential and a diverse cultural and international experience but a spotty record.
    I’m 28 now and I want to know if I have a shot at HBS considering the totality of my circumstances.
    Your consideration and advice is sincerely appreciated.

  • Linda Abraham

    Jay,
    I’m not optimistic about your chances at HBS. you certainly have a chance, but I doubt it. I think you need to apply at a range of schools. Many will appreciate your story and GMAT. But others, and I think HBS is among them, will look down at a college degree that is largely CLEPs. They may also question whether store management is competitive work experience for a top MBA program, depending on the size of the store, the volume, the number of employees, etc.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Rohan

    Dear Linda,
    I had a question on a particular essay asked by HBS: What would you like the MBA Admissions Board to know about your undergraduate academic experience? Does the answer have to be "academic" in nature meaning relating to grades or classes etc or can it be a community impact you had on campus? I was on the board of the international student association at my college (Top 50 liberal arts College in USA). There was an incident on campus where two African American students were accused of rape. What followed was a lot of racial and stereotypical discrimination and hostility on campus. As part of the organization I led the launch of the "Wall" campaign. We built a 10 foot by 10 foot brick wall in the heart of campus on which students could write stereotypes that they have experienced. After a week, we took hammers and broke the wall down symbolizing breaking of common stereotypes. As you can imagine the impact was huge with the entire campus getting involved. It was a lot of work getting everyone on board and getting the approvals from the college deans but it turned out to be a huge success and major impact on the community. Now can I write about this experience or does it not fall under the "academic" undergraduate experience? Also, would HBS care for this experience? This can also fall under the other essay: Discuss how you have engaged with a community or organization. However, I feel I would only be comfortable writing about a college experience if the question directly asked it as in 3a.
    Thanks,
    Rohan

  • Linda Abraham

    Since the questions specifies "academic," to be on the safe side it should relate to academics. It could be how your activism in this case stemmed from a class you took or something you learned in an academic context. But if this response did not relate to an academic aspect of your college career, I think it is a little off base. You then have a judgment call to make as whether you want to use it anyway and stretch/ignore "academic" in the question because it sounds like a great example of leadership.

    On the other hand this experience also sounds like a great answer to #2. It really fits it perfectly. How long are you out of college that you are so concerned about discussing this experience in that context?

    Finally, could you use this experience as one of your three accomplishments?

    Linda

  • Rohan

    Thank you for the quick reply. I graduated from college in 2007. So its been over 2 years. Would it still make sense to use it in essay #2? As far as the accomplishment essay goes, I feel I have more impactful experiences in personal, community and professional life.

  • Linda Abraham

    Makes sense for the accomplishment essay.

    I don’t know what you alternatives are, but I really think that this example would be an excellent response for #2. It shows you as a leader several years ago and as an active, involved member of your community. And 2007 is not SO long ago.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Rohan

    Thank you that helps. As a follow up to this, I was wondering what "evidence" needs to be provided of having done something like this? As I will not be having a recommendation from college, this experience will not be validated through a recommender. I do have photos of the event plus the organization has a website where my name and position is listed. However, I will not be providing this information in the application. How does the validation process work in this case and is there anything that I need to provide?

  • Linda Abraham

    They will check veracity of you are admitted, and I don’t claim a lot of expertise in background checks. But if there was publicity about the event, including a web site and perhaps school newspaper articles, it will be verified with no problem.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Siddhesh

    Hi Linda,

    I’m a first year engineering student from India and would like to apply to HBS after graduating. What kind of things do you suggest i should get on my resume in the next four years to make a good impression?
    Thanks,
    Siddhesh.

  • Linda Abraham

    Leadership, leadership, and more leadership. Take an active role in campus clubs and organizations. Be able to show impact.

    Also be realistic, while HBS does have its 2+2 program it accepted only one student straight from college last year. You might be wiser to work for a year or two after finishing your undergraduate education before you apply.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Poly

    Linda,
    Thanks for your answer.

  • WL

    Hi Linda,

    What do you think of my chances?
    GMAT: 680, 78% verbal/79% quant breakdown
    GPA: 3.5
    Work experience: 1.5yrs in IB at UBS, 1.5 yrs in microfinance for eastern europe
    extras: on board of several orgs in college, American living in Germany, started expat group in Germany.

    Thanks!

  • Siddhesh

    Hi again,
    Thank you for your quick response to my previous question. While extra-curricular activities are important, academically what kind of score should i have(in percentage)? (Note: I’m from Mumbai and our university topper usually has a score of around 81-83%). What is the percentage to gpa conversion that HBS follows? Also, when do you suggest that i appear for gmat?
    Thanks,
    Siddhesh.

  • MH

    Hi Linda,

    I worked as a project analyst on multi-million projects for 1.5 years in a fortune 100 company and then started a small business last year. We now have customers in many other countries. Undergrad GPA: 3.75. GMAT: 750.
    I see that many other applicants have many years of work experience and I only have 2 years of experience. Do I have any chance to be selected for HBS? Thank you.

  • G

    Linda,

    I am currently applying to HBS – 3.3 undergrad gpa (in a natural science) from top 3 public/top 25 school. Do you believe that this low gpa warrants an extra essay on its behalf, or will they understand given the tougher major? I have a strong gmat and great work exp (IB and bus dev/strategy). Let me know what you think. Thanks!

    G

  • Himanshu

    Hi Linda,

    I am 26,have 3.5 years of work experience as a Petrophysicist in a petroleum Company in India and I have 7.78/10 CGPA in my M.Sc Geology from IIT, a very reputed engineering college in india.I have B.Sc from Delhi University where I was University 2nd Topper with 71% marks.
    I dont have significant extra curricular achievements. I am good at essays and have won many university level essay competitions.
    My doubts are:
    Whats my GPA according to HBS roughly?
    I wish to apply in 2011 -2013 session.
    is it right to take GMAT in 2010 JAN.Whats the score I should target? Please suggest me in points – How can I make myself wanted at HBS in the 1.5 years that I have with me.

  • Jack

    Hi Linda,

    Do you know what questions are asked to the recommenders apart from the ones stated on HBS website?

    (HBS states that "Recommendations must be completed online. The form includes the following three essay response questions, along with other types of questions.")

    What "other types of questions" are meant?

    Regards,

    Jack

  • KYB

    Hi Linda,
    Thanks for the feedback you’ve been providing here – it’s definitely very valuable. i also have a profile question for you – my gmat is 730, but it’s 99th pct verbal and only 63rd pct quant. my college gpa was 3.38, from Harvard, with some other quant courses graded mostly as "B/B+". will that be a redflag for HBS AdCom in my application? should i even bother applying? i think my asset is my experience working for Lehman Bros before the bankruptcy and a few leadership posts during college…

  • Ab

    Linda,

    I hope you are doing well. I want to build a career in a non-profit firm working for poverty alleviation post MBA.

    I did my graduation from IIT Mumbai with a GPA of 4.0 (GMAT = 740; awa = 4.0). I have been working in a marketing consultancy since (3 years) then. I have worked on Indian and US projects and have spent about a year in US for the same. I have also been a volunteer in a social advocay firm since last two years. That gave me an opportunity to perform in-depth analysis of poverty and its causes and is the motivation for a career in non-profit after MBA.

    Do you feel I should go for Harvard given my profile and interest?

  • Linda Abraham

    WL,

    Sorry about my tardy response. I was on vacation.

    Your stats are a little low for HBS, but your experience and int’l experience is impressive. Basically, I think you have a chance, but it isn’t a good one. Apply, but don’t set your heart on Harvard.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Siddesh,

    Sorry about my tardy response. I was on vacation.

    I don’t mean to be evasive or flippant, but you want aim for the best average you can get. Ideally you want first class honors. In terms of percentages it should be over 70%. Take the GMAT when you feel you will be best prepared for it. I suspect that time will be right after you finish school and before you start work.If you want to apply while still in school, then take the test roughly six months before you intend to apply. That way if you don’t do well, you can retake.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    MH,

    Sorry about my tardy response. I was on vacation.

    I do think you have a chance at HBS and encourage you to apply to HBS as well as other top programs.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Siddhesh

    Thank you. That was very important. I’ll start working towards it right now and keep my fingers crossed.
    Best,
    Siddhesh.

  • Linda Abraham

    G.

    If you ranked highly in your program, you may want to include that ranking somewhere in your application so that you give context to your GPA. But merely saying that your GPA is below HBS’ average because you assume your major is significantly harder than the majors of others applicants, many of whom come from technical majors also, probably won’t help your cause and could hurt it. If there were extenuating factors that hurt your GPA, it may make sense to inform HBS of those circumstances, but I don’t think a "hard" major qualifies as extenuating circumstances.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Sorry for my slow response. I was on vacation. To answer your questions.

    You are best off not translating your GPA. HBS will know how to interpret it. I can tell you that it is competitive and that your schools are well-known at HBS.

    Jan 2010 is a good time to take the GMAT if you want to apply in Fall 2010. Target the highest score you can get. :-)

    The most important activity for you now if you want to gain acceptance at HBS is to seek out leadership roles both on and off the job. You don’t need fancy titles, but you do want to show that you have assumed responsibility, led others, and had impact. Doing so may be difficult on the job, and is usually easier to do in volunteer organizations that always need dedicated, talented people.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Jack,

    Sorry about the delayed response. I was on vacation.

    Here is what I know, thanks to Accepted editor Jennifer Bloom, who checked it out.

    There are questions about the recommender’s title and relationship to the applicant, how many applicants he is recommending this year, the chart of qualities (leadership potential, self confidence, personal maturity, professional maturity, imagination and creativity, motivation, intellectual ability, analytical ability, quantitative ability, teamwork skills, listening skills, ability in oral expression, ability in written expression, self-awareness, global perspective/awareness, interpersonal skills with subordinates, interpersonal skills with superiors) with a 500 character box for explaining any of those ratings, and of course the three short essay questions with the 250-word limits:

    · Please comment on the context of your interaction with the applicant. How long have you known the applicant and in what connection? If applicable, briefly describe the applicant’s role in your organization. (250-word limit)

    · Please describe the most important piece of constructive feedback you have given the applicant. Please detail the circumstances and the applicant’s response. (250-word limit)

    · Please make additional statements about the applicant’s performance, potential, or personal qualities you believe would be helpful to the MBA Admissions Board. (250-word limit)

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    KYB

    Sorry for the delayed response. I was on vacation.

    I do think your quant percentile and so-so performance in quant classes in college could be a red flag. Lehman experience, while good, and a few leadership experiences are unlikely to overcome the (for HBS) mediocre numbers — unless you retake the GMAT, which might be a good idea for you to do. Frankly, you will have the hurdle at most top MBA programs. IF you are aiming for top ten, I think you should retake.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    AB,

    Your academic stats are certainly competitive for HBS. The question of leadership comes up again. If you have had leadership roles on and off the job including college, then I think you should apply to HBS. If you can’t demonstrate leadership, then I think you should on applying to HBS.

    Best,
    Linda

  • John

    Dear Linda,
    thank you very much for the valuable input you have been giving here. I would like to take the opportunity to also ask about your feeling regarding my stats: I have a GMAT score of 710 (97% Verbal, 74% Quant), have a computer science background (as GPA I got a 1.2 on a 1-5 scale, 1 being best), and have worked +3 years at a fortune 100 company (including project leadership positions and significant board visibility).

    What do you think about my chances? Would my GMAT score be *the* deal breaker here?

    Thank you and best regards
    John

  • Linda Abraham

    John,

    The GMAT score is not looked at in a vacuum. So if you have a lot of quant courses and A’s in them, I don’t think your quant GMAT score will be a dealbreaker. If your quant grades are not so good and they reinforce the GMAT, then you may have a problem.

    Best,
    Linda

  • KYB

    Linda, thanks a lot for your frank response. May I follow up with another question please? The thing is that most application resources out there explicitly do not recommend re-taking the GMAT after scoring 700+, so would it be more prudent to address my quant weakness in the optional essay perhaps? More specifically, I’m thinking of trying to counter my Bs in AppMath and Stats with As in Accounting and Corp Finance (from MIT Sloan as an ugrad nonetheless), and my passing of the CFA Lev1 exam last December…

  • John

    Dear Linda,

    thank you very much for your input. Now, I do not think that my undergraduate experience reinforces the GMAT quant, as computer science contains lots of math and I was a straight A scorer. Unfortunately, my university does not list classes on a very detailed level, but rather the transcripts only provide the grades for the areas of study (such as theoretical computer science, or for the final thesis). Hence, the grades are all great, but there are no line items mentioning that "calculus" or "probability theory" was part of the graded area.

    Do you think I shall explain this somehow, maybe in an optional essay? Or can I rely that the admission officers know that math is very crucial for CS. I have also been a teaching assistant for three years in a mathematical logics class.

    If you still see a problem, I would consider redoing the gmat, just to be on the safe side.

    Thank you very much for your input. I highly appreciate it.

    Best regards
    John

  • Mary

    Hi Linda,

    This is a general question. I was laid off due to workforce reduction in the automobile industry at the end of last year. Then I started my own business and acquired financial sponsorship. Should I mention about the layoff in my application or just mention that I began to pursue other business opportunities after I left the previous employer? Thank you for your help!

  • Linda Abraham

    KYB, you can certainly try to compensate for the 63% in Q in this manner. I’m just not sure it is as effective as a higher score. (BTW, I also normally don’t recommend retaking 700+ GMATs, but there are always exceptions and 63% in quant makes me reassess.)

    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    John, I think you’re right and that you do not need to retake. I also think that CS has enough math in it that your transcript and grades speak for themselves.

    Linda Abraham

  • Linda Abraham

    Mary,

    The layoff, especially at that point in time, is really not a big deal. Many applications will ask why you left an employer and you can say "lay off." The schools will be more interested in your response to the layoff than the layoff itself.

    Best,
    Linda

  • KYB

    Linda, this was very helpful, thanks a lot!

  • John

    Linda,

    thank you very much for you answer. Very much appreciated.

    Best regards,
    John

  • Johnson

    Hi Linda

    I have a GPA of a 3.38 from state undergrad business school. I studied Economics. I have a GMAT of a 680. I am from Senegal. Would you consider my academic profile competitive?

  • JL

    Linda,

    some other questions:

    1.how are international applications evaluated? Do they get away with lower GMAT scores? Is the emphasis the same on the quant and verbal?

    2. If there are little applicants from a given country, does that mean ur chances get better?

    3. How important is the family background? Parents hold university degrees vs. nobody holds degrees in teh ancestory.

    4. Dual Citizenship: helps or hurts? How important can a Permanent Residency be?

    Thx,
    JL

  • Linda Abraham

    Johnson,

    Your GMAT and GPA are on the lower end of competitive, but I can’t say based on that and your nationality if you have a competitive profile for HBS or not. As I have said repeatedly above, leadership experience is critical if you want to attend HBS.

  • Linda Abraham

    JL
    1) International applicants are evaluated in the context of the applicant pool as a whole. B-schools will sometimes be a LITTLE more lenient on the verbal score for international applicants. Still, international applicants must be fluent in English or they will not be able to cope with the workload.

    2) Top MBA programs value diversity. My sense is that competitive applicants from under-represented countries have a better chance of acceptance than those from over-represented countries and backgrounds.
    3) Family background is of little importance. Schools may give brownie points if you are the first in your family to attend college, but other factors are more important.
    4) Dual Citizenship and permanent residency mean you don’t have the hurdle of sponsorship when you graduate if you want to work in the US. It may help you if you say you want to remain in the US. It doesn’t matter if you want to work outside the US.

    Linda

  • LV

    Hi,

    Would an in house counsel looking to augment business skills interest HBS?

  • Ricardo

    Hi Linda,

    Thanks for your helpful posts.

    Academics – I’ve got an interesting situation. I have a 3.3 GPA from a state school in Los Angeles and wrote a 720 GMAT. I studied macro economics. The problem is that even my grades slope downwards since my junior year. What are your thoughts on my academics?

    I am from brazil, and I moved to America in 2000. I joined the US army after Sept 11 and served in Iraq for a year. Also did a couple of countryside missions. I left the army as a sergeant in 2007.

    In my junior year, I was part of SEO and completed an internship in investment banking at Lehman brothers. I was also part of Harvard’s SVMP program that same year.

    I have tons of leadership experience from the army, undergrad and at work. I also run a nonprofit right now.

    After school, I couldn’t secure a work visa so I decided to move back to brazil. I now work with a Japanese investment bank based in brazil and will be completing my second year later this summer.

    I hope to attend HBS but I have mixed feelings about my candidacy. Would you be kind to shed some light on my candidacy? My academics is also a major cause for concern…

    thanks

  • Linda Abraham

    LV,

    That would depend obviously on your academic credentials, but less obviously on the leadershp potential you have demonstrated and the leadership responsibility you want to take on in the future. Your position as in-house counsel is neither a plus nor a minus. It’s what you did in that role and others that counts.

    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Ricardo,

    Everything except your GPA looks competitive for HBS, but I share your concern about your GPA, especially since your grades trended down.

    You need to address the circumstances that contributed to the decline and show that those circumstances are no longer affecting your performance either because they no longer exist or because you’ve learned how to deal with them.

    If you would like help with this task, please let me know. (http://www.accepted.com/services/register.aspx )

    Best,
    Linda

  • Daniel

    Hi Linda,

    I am from India and planning to apply to HBS this year. I have 5 years of experience including 4 years in research and analytics, and 1 year in manufacturing. I have done my Bachelors of Technology from Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Delhi with a CGPA of 6.1/10. Also, I have a technical research paper published to my name.

    My GMAT score is 680 (quant’s percentile: 94).

    I have 4 years of experience in community service. I founded CSR group, which is now a company-wide initiative, 3 years back and have led many sustainability initiatives within and outside the company. In addition, I have good leadership experience from my undergrad.

    What are my chances?

    Thanks,
    Daniel

  • Norbert

    Hi Linda,

    I read your analysis with great interest. Can you provide your opinion on whether I should apply for HBS?

    Male
    2 years out of University
    2 years Working for Microsoft (incl. Promotion and Jobrolechange)
    had small startups during university
    GMAT 720 (quant 90 % / verbal 88 %)
    Germany
    CTO of a biotech startup
    Masters in Engineering (among 16% – not good enough?)
    exchange semester in Australia

    thanks a lot for your advice,
    Norbert

    ps: is there a difference in applying for round 1 or 2? (is the second round harder?)

  • Linda Abraham

    Daniel,

    While I think you would be competitive at many fine MBA programs, I don’t see a fit with HBS for you. You are coming from a very crowded sub-group in the applicant pool, your stats are below average for HBS and what you wrote above does not present evidence of an unusually rapid career progression or leadership. Yes, your ECs are impressive, but I don’t think they alone will do it. I don’t think it makes sense for you to apply. Sorry.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Norbert,

    It makes sense for you to apply to HBS along with other programs.

    Regarding the R1 vs R2 question I think Dee Leopold recently addressed that question on her blog. I addressed it at http://blog.accepted.com/acceptedcom_blog/2005/7/18/mba-admission-the-great-round-1round-2-fight.html .

    Best,
    Linda

  • Helen

    Hi Linda,

    I am currently an undergrad at a university in the USA. I have my vision set out for HBS like the many real estate developer I had read about.

    My current GPA is below a 3.0 but if I finish strong in the last 2 years (for my Construction Management B.S.), I could get at most 3.5. I need your advice on what I should do from this moment on to increase my chances.
    Should I also start on my GMAT study? What kind of leadership skill are they asking for (start up venture or business or management types)? Should I try to double degree in business or finance?
    Thank you for your time.

    Sincerely,
    Helen

  • Nikhil

    Dear Linda:

    I have the following question regarding the resume that needs to be submitted as part of the application process.

    I am an Electrical Engineer by profession. Therefore, my résumé usually contains a lot of technical terms (for example, names of various systems, softwares, tools and equipment). However, I may be able to modify it to tone down the technical information which may make the résumé more suitable for applying to HBS. Does the Admissions Committee prefer a more technical (as it would be for a job application) or less technical (suitable for HBS application) version?

    Your advice is greatly appreciated.
    Thanks

  • Linda Abraham

    Helen,

    If you finish with a 3.5, your overall GPA would be competitive at HBS. Obviously, that is not the only element, but it is an important factor in evaluating your application.

    Don’t start on your GMAT prep yet.

    Leadership can take many forms and be in almost any venue. It doesn’t have to be in business. It can be in your church, on-campus club, sports team, political cause. Just take responsibility for something that requires you to lead.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Nikhil,

    Less technical and more business or managment oriented.

    Linda

  • James

    Linda,

    I’m applying to HBS, but I fear that I may be too old from what I’m reading.
    -28
    -5 years of PE in NYC
    -740 (48 Q, 44 V)
    -3.9 GPA from top 30 public univ
    -Eagle Scout (high school, but still means a lot)
    -some meaningful volunteer work but haven’t saved the world by any stretch

    Do I have any shot, given solid essays and a solid interview? Or should I focus on Wharton, CBS, Kellogg?

    Thanks,
    James

  • Linda Abraham

    James,

    Age is not the sole criterion and you do have a shot at HBS, but you are older than the typical successful HBS applicant.

    Should you focus on the other programs that have higher average age at matriculation and where you may fit better? I can’t answer that question based on this post.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Sreeram

    Hey Linda,

    Question: I am an engineering graduate from India. Graduated from India’s best under-grad institution post which I went to work for a global consumer goods company. Moved on after a couple of years to start my own venture. This venture was recently voted amongst ‘India’s Top 10 startups in 2009′. My GMAT score is 780. Have a bunch of extra-curriculars that have kept me active.

    What shot do you think I have at HBS?

    Thanks
    Sreeram

  • Linda Abraham

    Assuming you also had good grades in college, you have a shot at HBS and should give it a try, if it appeals to you. If you would like help with your application, please let us know.

  • BM

    Linda:

    Thank you for taking the time and helping us out. You’re putting wind in our sails and pointing us in the right direction.

    I am not necessarily applying to HBS but wanted to know if I have a good shot or should be focusing on some other schools.

    -24 (3 years in China, 3 years in Japan, 9 years in Canada and 9 years in the US)
    -2 years as a financial advisor associate (sales)
    -Diverse experience from having worked in different ares (municipal bond trading, financial advising, strategic consulting, IT consultant, fitness coordinator)
    -760 (50 Q, 44 V) and 6.0 AWA
    -3.165 GPA from a top 5 Liberal Arts School (grade is low but trends upwards)
    -Treasurer for the NY chapter of the largest Pan-Asian-American organization in North America / Board Member of Minneapolis chapter
    -Student body senator / Chair of 400+ member Asian students organization

    If I can write a few quality essays and secure some outstanding recs, what do you think my chances are to these schools?
    -Wharton
    -Columbia
    -Dartmouth
    -MIT
    -Yale
    -Harvard

  • hans

    Hi Linda,

    do you think that the optional essay is the reight place for a Why HBS essay? Where would this fit with the given questions?

    Regards,

    Hans

  • Linda Abraham

    BM,

    Thanks for your feedback.

    I am understanding that for the last two years you have been working as a financial advisor associate (sales) and for one employer and that the other work consisted of part-time and summer work prior to graduation.

    I am concerned that your GPA will be a big problem at your target schools. Perhaps if I knew the reason or saw the extent of the upward trend, I would be a little more encouraging. At the moment, I would say you need to choose perhaps two from this list (your "stretch" schools) and then apply to other (maybe 3-4) slightly lower ranked programs. Alternatively, use this year to build an alternative transcript with recent A’s and then apply in Fall 2010 to matriculate in Fall 2011.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Hans,

    I wouldn’t write a Why HBS essay. They aren’t asking for that information. Answer their questions and give them what they want.

    They also do not give you the option of writing an optional essay.

    Best,
    Linda

  • LV

    Dear Linda,

    I had written earlier too. I am from India where I studied in arguabky the best law school and finished in top 20% of university. For 4 years I have been an in house counsel in a leading consumer goods company. I have led teams and demonstrted leadership in several initiatives. Besides, I have volunteered as well as continued to teach at University as well. I am looking at MBA to augment business skills in areas os negotiation, leadership development, marketing. I aim to continue business advisory in an in house counsel capacity. I have not come across a law grad switching to a business dgree yet. Will this switch make me look like a confused person? Or an in house role will be treated just as any other techie, consulting role?

  • Nate

    Linda –

    I’m wondering what my chances are of admission to a top 5 (particularly Kellogg, HBS, Wharton, Chicago).
    Nationality: American (White)
    Gender: Male
    GMAT: 710
    UGPA: 3.5 (Major in Econ, Major GPA over 3.7) Big 10 School
    Work Experience: 7 Years with Fortune 100 Company – 4 of those years overseas in Asia.
    Thanks.
    Nate

  • Frankie

    Hi Linda,

    I want to apply HBS by the end of 2010.

    Male

    26 years old

    2.9/4.0 BS Accounting and Finance from Big Ten school

    GMAT: 710

    4 years of prof. experience ( 3 years of analyst experience from Wells Fargo Asset Management and 1 year experince in a high-tech company)

    CFA levl II and pass 2 subjects in the CPA exam (hopefully, this can accommodate my low GPA.)

    Microfinance NPO consulting in Beijing for 6 months.

    Treasurer for Delta Sigma Pi (Professional Business Fraternity)

    Team Leads (Hands-On Bay Area)

    Do I still have a shot at HBS? I know I have a horrible ugrad GPA….

    Regards,
    Frankie

  • Jose27

    Hi, Linda, I was wondering if I have a shot at HBS given my following background.

    - I came from Peru when I was 15.5 years old
    - I have a BS in Mechanical Engineering, with a GPA of 3.41 from a top public university in New England area. My GPA is not that good, but I was able to graduate in 2.5 years (5 semesters) at the age of 20. I was able to finish earlier due to the high number of classes i took per semester, advance placement (AP) classes i took in high school, and high school partneship program classes I took in a community college.
    - I got a GMAT of 720
    - I currently worked as a design engineer for 3.3 years in a leading automotive sensor technology company. I have had some leading roles at different projects, I had been able to obtain merit bonuses a couple of times due to my excellent performance (those bonuses were separate from the standard bonuses at the end of the year). I know I can get very recommendations from my supervisors.
    - One drawback is that I have not had too many extracurricular activities during school. I was just a member in different honor societies.
    - During my professional life, I have been able to do community service: mentoring middle school children. In addition, I had been a very active member in two professional Hispanic societies trying to promote education welfare to children, and disadvantaged adults. In addition, I have lately become active member in non-profit organizations. Could this help somehow offset my previous lack of extracurricular activities in school?
    - During these last 2-2.5 years in my company, I have also worked towards my Masters in Mechanical Engineer in a good recognized private school, I am accelerating to complete my masters in ME this fall 09 semester at the age of 24, I am taking a total of 4 classes (2 ME and 2 MBA classes). I will be getting a GPA of 3.8 at this time. I am confident I will ace all my classes. Could this help offset my low GPA of 3.41 at undergrad school? Could this core MBA classes (accounting, finance) help too? I plan to take also additional core MBA classes (marketing, operation management) on the spring 2010 to help me build my business knowledge.
    -From my personal life, I was able to buy a family house at the age of 22, and also I am currently a landlord.
    -So my question is that if I have some chance at HBS. Do I have some advantage as a minority since I come from Peru?
    -I am 24 years old right now. If so, should I apply at round 2 for fall 2010 admission, or should I wait to apply at round 1 or round 2 to apply for Fall 2011 admission?
    I could use that extra time to build more on the leadership and community service roles, get important titles in those organizations now that I am well known there. or could the age of 25 (when you are applying) be considered too old for HBS?
    If you do not think I do have a chance, what other top business school could I possibly consider?
    thanks

  • Paul

    Linda:

    Thanks for answering all our questions! Your feedback is so candid, so I’d really appreciate your take on my odds at HBS:

    Economics/Psychology Major,
    Business/History Minor
    GPA 3.42 at U of Wisconsin
    5 years work experience (3 at Fortune 40 company)
    740 GMAT (85%Q, 95%V)

    VP of Community Service in NSCS in college
    Currenty volunteer as inner-city tutor and serve on Junior Board of Directors for tutoring program

    Unfortunately, I didn’t come across this great website until today…I wrote my "mistake" essay about how one of my biggest mistakes was my inaction (lack of leadership) earlier in my life. At least I wrote about how I learned from my mistake. I wish I would have read accepted.com’s advice earlier! Did I completely blow my chances at HBS?

    Thanks again,

    Paul

  • Paul

    Also, I just passed Level I of the CFA exam

  • Linda Abraham

    LV,

    Neither. There are lawyers who decide to pursue an MBA and they apply, admittedly in small numbers, every year. They are not considered "confused," unless they present ambiguous goals, and they are not considered meer techies unles they present themselves as legal drones.

    You need to present your experience as provdiing a valuable perspective on the business world.

    Best,
    Linda Abraham

  • Linda Abraham

    Nate,

    The information you provided is competitive at the schools you listed. However, many of those rejected from those schools will have similar stats and numbers. Fit, leadership, initiative, and impact will determine which group you end up in.

    I also think that in general terms, HBS prefers younger applicants.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Frankie,

    You do have a shot, but it’s not a good one, unless you can demonstrate an extraordinary level of leadership and impact Sorry.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Jose27

    To answer your questions:

    Yes, your recent community service does somewhat offset your previous lack of community service, although it is not as good as community service throughout.
    Yes your grad GPA does help offset a mediocre, but not low undergrad GPA.

    Yes, As in add’l business-related core courses will help too.

    Yes you have a chance at HBS and coming from Peru makes you part of an under-represented group, which will help you.

    You are not considered too old for HBS at 25. If you think you will have better leadership experience next year, then waiting is probably a good idea. If you think you are ready now and that your career has plateaued, then apply now.

    I do definitely think you have a chance, but you still should apply to other programs too. What do you want to do after your MBA?

    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Linda:

    Thanks for answering all our questions! Your feedback is so candid, so I’d really appreciate your take on my odds at HBS:

    Economics/Psychology Major,
    Business/History Minor
    GPA 3.42 at U of Wisconsin
    5 years work experience (3 at Fortune 40 company)
    740 GMAT (85%Q, 95%V)

    VP of Community Service in NSCS in college
    Currenty volunteer as inner-city tutor and serve on Junior Board of Directors for tutoring program

    Unfortunately, I didn’t come across this great website until today…I wrote my "mistake" essay about how one of my biggest mistakes was my inaction (lack of leadership) earlier in my life. At least I wrote about how I learned from my mistake. I wish I would have read accepted.com’s advice earlier! Did I completely blow my chances at HBS?

    Thanks again,

    Paul,

    I didn’t read your essays, but if you said that you learned your lesson in the mistake essay and showed leadership and initiative later as a result, you did not blow your chances. Still HBS is always a tough school. Don’t count on HBS.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Dustin

    Hi Linda,

    Thanks so much for answering our questions. You and Accepted.com are fantastic.

    I plan to reapply to HBS this year after being rejected two classes ago. In the middle of the hurricane of stress that is Harvard Law School 1L, I decided to apply only a couple months before the third round deadline (I wanted to do the four-year J.D./M.B.A. program). I didn’t/couldn’t put as much time as I needed into the essays and into researching HBS. For example, In answer to the question "Tell us something you learned from a mistake" I talked about how I left Teach for America early and I failed because I didn’t try with my whole heart (my answer to the essay on a defining leadership experience showed how I bounced back and learned from this mistake.) I think my essays in general also stepped into various pitfalls and showed a lack of understanding of HBS and what they look for in an applicant.

    I think perhaps potentially most damaging is that my career vision has changed dramatically from a year and a half ago. I am worried that this lack of consistency will make me seem at best like a candidate that doesn’t plan ahead or stick with decisions and at worst disingenuous.

    I otherwise have a competitive application. GMAT of 720 (99% verbal, 75% quant), GPA of 4.0 at a top-tier university. I have lots of leadership experience: supervised 200 volunteer representatives during a two year mission for my church; co-founded and co-presided a club with 100 members while an undergrad; during the two years before law school I worked as a research associate in a political science department at a top-tier university and supervised different research projects carried out by teams ranging from five to twenty persons; the summer before last I helped recruit, train, and supervise 400 volunteer exit pollsters for a November 2008 city-wide exit poll that was accurate within one tenth of a percentage point. I also have lots of community service and some time studying abroad. I graduate from HLS this spring and am 28 years old.

    Am I wasting my time reapplying? Do you have any suggestions for addressing my change in career vision?

    Thank you!

  • Dustin

    P.S. I am applying round 2 because I am out of the country doing a semester abroad until December.

  • Linda Abraham

    Dustin,

    Thanks for the feedback.

    I wouldn’t worry about the change in career goals/vision. It’s two years later, and you are allowed to grow and change in the course of those two years.

    As you say the rest of your application appears competitive so I don’t think that applying again is a waste of time. It’s just a HBS, competitiveness doesn’t equal acceptance. What’s important is that your goal requires an MBA and is realistic given your previous experiences and a Harvard MBA.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Jenn

    Dear Linda,

    I am from Singapore, 3 years out of college, and worked at Lehman Brothers Investment Banking in New York and Hong Kong. After Lehman went bankrupt, I joined a start-up hedge fund with some of my ex-team members.

    I graduated from Brown with a 3.2 and scored 720 on my GMAT. President of a club during college and involved in various community activities.

    Do I have a chance?

    Appreciate very much.
    -Jenn

  • Dipta

    Linda,

    I am a recent graduate of an average state school. Currently, I am a Logistics Officer for the US Air Force in Okinawa, Japan, where I am in charge of over $650 million in assets and over 220 people. I’ve worked full time since I was 14 (currently 23), employed with Foot Locker, Ralphs Supermarket, Verizon, and Wells Fargo Bank. I’ve also owned and managed two small retail businesses. Before I became an Officer, I was an enlisted jet mechanic for the Air Force Reserves. I was born and raised (until the age of 8) in Bangladesh and know 4 different languages. I aspire to attend Harvard Business School if I get out of the Air Force in 2013 (when my current contract expires). I am currently working on an Online MBA through Columbia College (Missouri). If I obtain an online MBA with a 3.8+ GPA, would this make up for a 3.1 undergrad GPA? What would you say my GMAT has to be for me to be competitive? Outside of getting involved in the community and professional organizations (which I already am), what can I do to improve my chances of being accepted.

  • Peter

    I am an international applicant from Asia.

    I got 710 on GMAT and 4.0 on AWA.

    My GPA is 3.2/4.0 (Undergrad at private college in US)

    My work expreinces include Investment Banking & managment consulting (3yrs total).

    Should I take GMAT again due to low AWA or focus on essays, etc?

  • Jeff

    Dear Linda,

    Firstly, I want to thank you for answering questions on this blog. They are very helpful.

    My situation is a lot different than an average applicant to Harvard. Since undergrad, I have been working for my family’s Textile Manufacturing business only (Last 15 years). I am from Pakistan and due to very bad security situation here, I have decided to start a new professional life in North America. To be successful in this move, I think MBA from a Top School is very important..
    Age: 34
    Citizen: Canada / Pakistan
    Undergraduate: B.Sc in Business Admin(USA) in 1995, Magna Cum Laude & B.Sc. in Textiles(USA) in 1996 3.82 GPA Summa Cum Laude.
    GMAT: 640 Last Year; will write again next month for better score.

    Do you think I have any chance with HBS, and if any advice you can give…

    Thanks,

    Jeff

  • Linda Abraham

    Jenn,

    If you can show leadership in your essays, you have a chance.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Dipta,

    To improve your chances, don’t get the online MBA. Many schools won’t consider applicants who already have an MBA. If you want to get a degree to show you know how to earn A’s (which could be a good idea), then get a degree in something related to your long-term goals, but not an MBA.

    If you have a strong post-college GPA and a competitive GMAT, you would be given serious consideration at HBS and other top schools. I would discourage you from focusing exclusively on HBS. Doing so is a recipe for failure.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Peter,

    AT this point, focus on the essays and also apply to other schools where you are more competitive.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Dear Linda,

    Firstly, I want to thank you for answering questions on this blog. They are very helpful.

    My situation is a lot different than an average applicant to Harvard. Since undergrad, I have been working for my family’s Textile Manufacturing business only (Last 15 years). I am from Pakistan and due to very bad security situation here, I have decided to start a new professional life in North America. To be successful in this move, I think MBA from a Top School is very important..
    Age: 34
    Citizen: Canada / Pakistan
    Undergraduate: B.Sc in Business Admin(USA) in 1995, Magna Cum Laude & B.Sc. in Textiles(USA) in 1996 3.82 GPA Summa Cum Laude.
    GMAT: 640 Last Year; will write again next month for better score.

    Do you think I have any chance with HBS, and if any advice you can give…

    Thanks,

    Jeff

    First of all, thanks for the feedback. You’re welcome.

    I am very pessimistic about your chances at HBS even with a higher GMAT. I encourage you to retake the GMAT )assuming you believe you can raise your score) and also consider other programs. There are many fine MBA programs besides Harvard.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Jeff

    Dear Linda,
    Thanks for your advice. I have been admitted to Queen’s University and York University in Canada already but I was more keen to do MBA from USA. Besides Harvard, I am applying to Kellogg, U. Chicago, and Cornell.
    You are pessimistic for Harvard due to older student factor, right?
    Thanks,
    Jeff

  • Jenn

    Dear Linda,

    Thank you so much for your candid advice. I have a follow-up question RE my previous post: would it increase my chances if I re-took the GMAT and scored a 750?

    Jenn

  • Linda Abraham

    Jeff,

    I am pessimistic because of your age, your GMAT, and because I am not sure that running a textile business for fifteen years is the kind of experience that Harvard will consider competitive. I’m not saying for sure that it isn’t because they do take people with different kinds of professional backgrounds, but I doubt it. And I am certain that the combination of all the above does not make me optimistic.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Jenn,

    It certainly wouldn’t hurt, but I honestly don’t believe it will make a big difference. I think leadership is going to be the critical factor.

    Linda

  • DD

    Dear Linda,

    I was wondering if you could let me know if I have a chance of getting accepted to HBS. I am applying to the MPP/MBA program and if accepted I would receive one of ten fellowships from the min. of finance from my country.
    I am a 23 year old Egyptian female(with dual nationality though). I have been working in a local company for 2 years in marketing. Although I have had one high appraisal and a recent promotion to supervisor, my responsibilities have increased a lot.
    - Bsc. with Honors. Double major.in business and strategic mgmt 3.8 GPA. (equivalent converted from German system) from a top Egyptian university
    - Actively involved in community work
    - Not-so-good score of 640 on GMAT but retaking next month
    - Lived in different countries. Speak 5 languages (with diff levels of proficiency)
    If I manage to improve my GMAT score by 50 + points, would I at least have a small chance of getting into HBS or Wharton?

  • Linda Abraham

    Yes. If you improve your GMAT by 50 points, you would have a competitive profile at both programs.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Staw

    Hi Linda,
    I am 26 years old, working in an international strategy consulting firm in the Middle East.
    Before that, I worked in consulting in Europe for 2 years.
    I got a score of 740 at the GMAT, 108 on the TOEFL, and I have a high GPA.
    I know that Harvard discourages to apply with less than 109 on the TOEFL.
    Do you think that they would still consider my application if applying with 108?
    Thank you

  • pr

    hey linda mam,
    i am a pre university student from india i.e. 11th grade student.
    i wish to pursue my MBA from the HBS.
    please guide me on what should i study while i would be an undergraduate andand how do i build up a stratergy for it?

    hoping for your generous reply…
    pr(16years)

  • Sam

    Hi Linda

    GMAT 700, Work Ex 4 years, Corporate Banking-Large Corporate Business India, what do you think are my chances of Harvard or other B schools?

    Sam

  • Teri

    Hi Linda,

    I’m an African American woman interested in applying to HBS. I graudated 5 years ago, have held various mid-management marketing positions (both agency and client-side)and founded an interent start-up about a year ago. I have a 720 GMAT score, but only a 3.0 gpa. Do you think I have a shot at HBS?

  • Joe

    Hi Linda,

    Thank you for taking the time to answer so many questions – this blog is fantastic. I have a question regarding my chances of admission to HBS.

    I took the GREs and scored 600V/800Q/5A. My background consists of 4 years as an actuary and 2 at a top investment bank. My extracurriculars are mostly focused on volunteer work within the industry.

    Would I have a chance at applying at HBS?

    Thanks in advance!

    Joe

  • YP

    Dear Linda,

    I am a 22 years old fresh graduate from Indonesia. I have worked on a contractual basis for 3 months after my graduation. Other than that, I have been working as a personal assistant for the president director: my father since 2003. Although I am not enlisted as a formal employee in the office, my scope of work enables me to tackle some managerial problems, work close with top clients and suppliers, and direct some subordinates in regards to my father’s function. During my high school years, I was very active in the student body, the youth red cross, and the debating club. I also had the opportunity to represent my university in the national debating championship. Sadly, I scored 600 on GMAT recently (27V, 46Q, 4.5AWA).

    Do you think that I have a chance on getting into Harvard MBA? Should I retake the GMAT?

    Thank you for your answers.

  • YP

    Sorry. I forgot to tell you that my GPA is 3.58.

    Thanks

    YP

  • Linda Abraham

    Staw,

    I’m not sure, but if they say they want 109 as a minimum, you would have to have very compelling evidence of skill in English to overcome the low TOEFL.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    pr,

    You have lots of time to worry about getting into HBS for an MBA. For now, study hard, get into a good school, get good grades, develop other interests, and take time to get involved and demonstrate leadership.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Sam,

    While I appreciate your conciseness, that’s not enough information for me to opine on your competitiveness.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Teri,

    You have a shot, but it isn’t a great one. Give it a try and see what happens. Also apply elsewhere. A lot will depend on how much leadership you can show, whether there was an upward trend to your grade, and if there were extenuating circumstances that contributed to the low GPA.

    Linda

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Joe,

    Could you provide the percentile scores for your GRE?

    Thanks,
    Linda

  • Joe

    Dear Linda,

    Thank you for the response. As a follow-up to my prior post, my GRE percentiles math/verbal/analytical are 86/94/81% (actual scores 600/800/5).

    Thanks,
    Joe

  • Joe

    Apologies, the above is verbal/math/analytical.

    Joe

  • Linda Abraham

    Joe,

    Thanks for your response and for the positive feedback you provided in your original post.

    My understanding is that the business schools are looking for 80th percentile and above scores on the GRE. Although I have not heard that specifcially from HBS, I did hear it from several other top b-school admissions directors.

    If your GPA is equally competitive and you have a lot of leadership, then you have a competitive profile for HBS.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    YP,

    I do not think you have a competitive profile for HBS and definitely think you need to retake the GMAT.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Jules

    Hi Linda

    I am 31yrs old from Holland.
    I worked for 6 yrs in trading (structured products)for an IB in london. I was the head of a trading team till november 2008 when i was laid off.
    My GMAT is 710
    I got a degree from a top engineering school in Holland (my results were in the top 20%). I also got a m.sc. in financial mathematics from UK where i got a 2.1 (but my results were not amazing, just good enough for a 2.1)
    After i was laid off, I travelled and volunteered for a few months in africa

    Should I give a shot for HBS? Or am I too old? Or the fact that i was made redundant is a big issue?

    Many thanks

  • Sabrina

    Hi Linda,

    I’m applying to the following schools in R2: HBS, Columbia, Cornell. I wish to specialize in entrepreneurship, and have specifically chosen these schools because of their VC connections and business "incubators". I’ve taken on considerable extra-curricular leadership in fitness and nutritional consulting, which is the industry I hope to start a business in immediately post-MBA.

    My stats:
    - Undergrad GPA: 4.0
    - Master’s GPA (economics): 4.0
    - Both degrees on scholarship
    - Completed MA at age 20
    - GMAT: 720, 48 Quant, 41 Verbal

    Work experience:
    - 3 years as economist at leading economic and public policy think tank in Canada
    - Extensive "thought" leadership–have advised governments extensively on economic policy and budgetary processes
    - Was headhunted at age 22 to be the head of economic advisory services to the Canadian Federal Minister for Industry (an executive level position), but financing fell through within the department as the recession broke. (Should I mention this point at all in my application? The position is unusually senior, and even being considered was an honour.)
    - Chief spokesperson for my organization on topics pertaining to fiscal policy, the automotive sector
    - Generated > $1 million in advertising revenues for a $30 million organization last year from appearances on national television, radio, newspapers.

    In your opinion, how can I "spin" my profile best to make a career as an entrepreneur logical?

    Many thanks,
    Sabrina

  • PhilY

    Hello, Linda, a great thanks in advance!

    I’m a 29 yrs old Eastern Asian, naturalized US citizen. I will be 29 at matriculation. I majored in Computer Engineering and GPA was 3.6. I was the treasurer of a fraternity and member of a couple of clubs. My GMAT score is 740 (48Q/44V).

    I’ve been a software engineer all my career and have been promoted twice indirectly when switching jobs and once at my current company directly. I’m considered a strategic/key employee for my company’s growth according to the senior management and have been compensated as such via bonus, which isn’t common for engineers. I’ve always had a leadership role of small teams throughout my career and directly supervised one or two employees at some points. My core leadership style is taking initiatives and my managers always complement me on it. I can’t say I’ve made any large organizational changes but I have made many small changes.

    My only EC outside of college are being a member of a couple of activity groups. I plan on working in the alternative energy field after MBA because I feel strongly about it but I have done nothing to show for my passion besides the words on my essays.

    If I’m the first and only member of my family to complete college and both of parents never finished middle school, would that just count for brownie points?

    My R2 probability of admission estimates are as follows:

    Harvard: 10-25%
    MIT: 25-33%
    Stanford: 10-25%

    Too high? I won’t be offended if you told me Harvard should really be 0-5%. I’d still try anyways.

    Because I’m satisfied with my career progression, I’m only considering the very best schools at this time or no MBA at all.

    Thanks, again, for reading my long post.

  • Linda Abraham

    Jules,

    I can’t say categorically that HBS will not admit 31-year old. They sometimes do. My sense is that they admit them in lower percentages than younger applicants. Your layoff doesn’t need to an automatic ding since you have been using your time in an interesting way.

    Basically, nothing you wrote above made me thing that you are a great or a terrible candidate for HBS. Most US b-schools want more European students so that’s in your favor. If you can show a track record of leadership, then give HBS a try,but also apply to other programs.

    What are your post-MBA goals?

    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Hi Linda,

    I’m applying to the following schools in R2: HBS, Columbia, Cornell. I wish to specialize in entrepreneurship, and have specifically chosen these schools because of their VC connections and business "incubators". I’ve taken on considerable extra-curricular leadership in fitness and nutritional consulting, which is the industry I hope to start a business in immediately post-MBA.

    My stats:
    - Undergrad GPA: 4.0
    - Master’s GPA (economics): 4.0
    - Both degrees on scholarship
    - Completed MA at age 20
    - GMAT: 720, 48 Quant, 41 Verbal

    Work experience:
    - 3 years as economist at leading economic and public policy think tank in Canada
    - Extensive "thought" leadership–have advised governments extensively on economic policy and budgetary processes
    - Was headhunted at age 22 to be the head of economic advisory services to the Canadian Federal Minister for Industry (an executive level position), but financing fell through within the department as the recession broke. (Should I mention this point at all in my application? The position is unusually senior, and even being considered was an honour.)
    - Chief spokesperson for my organization on topics pertaining to fiscal policy, the automotive sector
    - Generated > $1 million in advertising revenues for a $30 million organization last year from appearances on national television, radio, newspapers.

    In your opinion, how can I "spin" my profile best to make a career as an entrepreneur logical?

    Many thanks,
    Sabrina

    Sabrina,

    You have a competitive profile for HBS.

    I wouldn’t worry about "spin." Answer the questions in ways that reveal your attraction to and talent for entrepreneurship while also demonstrating leadership in multiple arenas. Given the impressive array of accomplishment you listed above, it shouldn’t be hard to do with authenticity, which is better than spin.

    You asked about mentioning a position that you received, but that you were not able to actually take because of the recession. You should try to mention it somewhere.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Hello, Linda, a great thanks in advance!

    I’m a 29 yrs old Eastern Asian, naturalized US citizen. I will be 29 at matriculation. I majored in Computer Engineering and GPA was 3.6. I was the treasurer of a fraternity and member of a couple of clubs. My GMAT score is 740 (48Q/44V).

    I’ve been a software engineer all my career and have been promoted twice indirectly when switching jobs and once at my current company directly. I’m considered a strategic/key employee for my company’s growth according to the senior management and have been compensated as such via bonus, which isn’t common for engineers. I’ve always had a leadership role of small teams throughout my career and directly supervised one or two employees at some points. My core leadership style is taking initiatives and my managers always complement me on it. I can’t say I’ve made any large organizational changes but I have made many small changes.

    My only EC outside of college are being a member of a couple of activity groups. I plan on working in the alternative energy field after MBA because I feel strongly about it but I have done nothing to show for my passion besides the words on my essays.

    If I’m the first and only member of my family to complete college and both of parents never finished middle school, would that just count for brownie points?

    My R2 probability of admission estimates are as follows:

    Harvard: 10-25%
    MIT: 25-33%
    Stanford: 10-25%

    Too high? I won’t be offended if you told me Harvard should really be 0-5%. I’d still try anyways.

    Because I’m satisfied with my career progression, I’m only considering the very best schools at this time or no MBA at all.

    Thanks, again, for reading my long post.

    Phil

    You’re most welcome.

    I’m sorry, but I am more pessimistic than you. I hate giving statistical odds because I know I am pulling numbers out of my thumb, but with that caveat, I would say your chances at HBS and Stanford are more in the 4-8% range and at MIT more like 5-10%.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Sabrina

    Thank you for a helpful and prompt answer, Linda!

    Best,
    Sabrina

  • Isaac

    Hi Linda,

    I’m applying R2 to HBS. I have 5 years work experience, working at one hedge fund for the entire duration. GMAT 760 (Q 50, V 44, AWA 6.0). Undergrad from Stanford with 3.4 GPA in Engineering. I don’t have many extracurriculars, but the one I do have I’m very involved with — I started an educational non-profit and have been doing that for the last 2+ years on my weekends.

    I’m weary that I’m on the older side for Harvard and that my GPA is a hindrance as well. My recs should be strong, both from founders of our fund and both former HBS grads.

    Can you please tell me if I’m competitive. Thanks in advance.

  • Jules

    many thanks Linda for your answer

    I am planning to continue my career in finance, even i might consider moving to a different area in IB. The reason i am considering a MBA is bc I would like broaden my skills.Do you think. May I ask you what you think about it?

    Kinds Regards

    Jules

  • Linda Abraham

    Isaac,

    You have a competitive profile for HBS. That doesn’t necessarily mean that accept you, but it means to me that your application will be taken seriously.

    If you would like help with it, please visit http://www.accepted.com/services/mbaservices.aspx .

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Jules,

    Given your background an MBA is a great vehicle for broadening your skills. It is a generalist and a management degree, especially at a program like HBS. So as I said above, apply to HBS, but also apply to other top GM programs like Kellogg, Chicago, Stanford, and Tuck. You may also want to consider Columbia, NYU, and Yale.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Jay

    Hi Linda,

    Thanks for the time you put in to help. Like everyone else I probably would like to assess my admissions chances, but for now I’ll just leave it at a broader question that is hopefully helpful to a few more people.

    When Harvard is talking about leadership, do you need to have a solid example about motivating and leader OTHER people?

    Or is personal leadership (e.g. taking control of your life, high achievement, starting something on your own) sufficient even if you are currently weaker on leading other people?

  • Linda Abraham

    Leadership usually involves leading other people. Harvard considers itself a developer of societal and business leaders.That implies leading others. Harvard is also very clear that it wants to develop leaders, not create them. I think self-leadership is usually a given at HBS. However, I can’t say categorically that it never sufficed.

    Initiative is definitely an aspect of leadership that Harvard looks for.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Richard

    Got into HBS yesterday!

    thanks Linda!

  • nks

    Hi Linda,

    Thanks for the time you put in.

    I am applying in R2 to HBS.

    my profile :

    1. 5.5 years of experience in sales in a Fortune 500 company.
    2. Currently leading a team of 900+ ,responsible for generating revenues of over 4800 million pa.
    3. Promoted under fast track in the company and also earned best officer trainee award.
    4. Gmat 710 ( VA 34 QA 50 AWA 5.5 ) – second attempt, first attempt score – 680 ( VA 30 QA 50 AWA 5.5)
    5. Undergraduate GPA – 3.3
    6. ECs : won lawn tennis state championship in school days and held many posts in school.
    7 No significant EC in college.
    8 international workx – 0
    9. Age – 26
    10 post mba i want to return back to my industry.

    given my low gmat ( 2nd attempt), below par GPA , much higher workx and no significant EC in college do i stand a chance at HBS. What other b schools would you suggest.

    Thanks

  • Melissa

    My work is paying for half of my MBA, but in finance banking and my long term goal is to work in non profit. How can i connect those to different paths in the vision question succintly? i believe coming back to the bank still provides lots of learning transferable leadership skills that will continue to accelerate my career upwards, until i can make that full transition.

  • kelly

    Hi Linda,

    do you think i have a chance?

    Age – mid 20′s
    GPA 4.0,
    GMAT 710
    Experience – 2 years finance (3 by time start); ranked as top analyst and have my md and head of department reference, exposed to very senior management of companies (treasurer, cfo level)
    International volunteer excurisions, local community involvement

  • Linda Abraham

    Richard,

    Congratulations! Thanks for sharing the great news!.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Hi Linda,

    Thanks for the time you put in.

    I am applying in R2 to HBS.

    my profile :

    1. 5.5 years of experience in sales in a Fortune 500 company.
    2. Currently leading a team of 900+ ,responsible for generating revenues of over 4800 million pa.
    3. Promoted under fast track in the company and also earned best officer trainee award.
    4. Gmat 710 ( VA 34 QA 50 AWA 5.5 ) – second attempt, first attempt score – 680 ( VA 30 QA 50 AWA 5.5)
    5. Undergraduate GPA – 3.3
    6. ECs : won lawn tennis state championship in school days and held many posts in school.
    7 No significant EC in college.
    8 international workx – 0
    9. Age – 26
    10 post mba i want to return back to my industry.

    given my low gmat ( 2nd attempt), below par GPA , much higher workx and no significant EC in college do i stand a chance at HBS. What other b schools would you suggest.

    Thanks

    NKS

    You’re welcome.

    I am not optimistic about your likelihood of acceptance at HBS for most of the reasons you cite.

    Before I recommend other programs, what industry are you in and what role do you want to assume when you return to it?

    Best,
    Linda

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Kelly,

    The information you provided above is competitive at HBS. If you also have strong demonstrated leadership, you would have a competitive profile.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Melissa,

    There are many ways you can connect them, but the most obvious is long-term and short-term.Long-term you want to do A,B,C in the not-for-profit world. Short-term you want to return to your current employer, who is sponsoring 50% of your tuition. Your immediate post-MBA position will have benefits X,Y, and Z when you transition to the NFP arena. Show how it all connects.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Mike

    Hi Linda,
    I wrote the GMAT twice and went up from 610 to 710, however my AWA mark went down from 5 to 4.5 which is like the 37%. Is this a deal breaker for me. .. I actually am shocked since I have always been told my writing skills are strong.

    Thanks in advance. Your blog is so helpful.

    Mike

  • Neeha

    Linda,
    Thank you for taking the time and sharing your expertise. I am 25, Indian, female. I am applying R2 and would like to know what you think of my chances at HBS and Stanford.
    1) 3.5 GPA from a top 15 private US national university
    2) GMAT 710
    3) 2 yrs IBD at top US investment bank
    4) Conducted NGO-focused research in India with academic fellowship for 1 yr
    5) 1 yr at US NGO, focused on econ dev

    Additional question: Do you think my below avg GPA is going to be a deal breaker? It is a result of some very high level quant classes early in my college career. Many thanks for your help and time!

  • Linda Abraham

    Mike,

    Thanks for the feedback and congrats on your improved GMAT.

    I would not worry about the drop in AWA score provided that you have lots of other evidence of writing ability and communications skills in your application.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Neeha,

    If you also have demonstrated leadership in your profile, you have a competitive profile for HBS. I don’t think HBS will wonder whether you have the ability to handle the work given your credentials.

    At the same time, a competitive profile doesn’t equal an accepted application. Don’t count on HBS until you get the acceptance.

    Best,
    Linda

  • nks

    Hi Linda,

    Thanks for prompt reply.

    I am working in oil sector and would like to return to the same sector at some marketing role

  • Mike J

    Hi Linda,

    Thanks for your blog For recommendations it shows the waive rights box to see them. Does this impact your admission’s view at all depending of which option you choose?

    Thanks
    Mike J

  • rebecca

    Hi Linda,

    With respect to the career vision question, I feel like it is such a challenge to be specific (ie) i want to climb the corporate in XX industry and be doing XX responsibilities and one day be the CEO. What would you advise or how specific does one need to be.

    rebecca james

  • rebecca james

    Hi Linda,

    Second quick question if you dont mind. My recommender is very high up, and i had several really key opportunities to impress her. She wrote what I think sounds like a strong recommendation (says i am top and contribute signifacant value) but only used 170-180 of the words vs. 250. is this going to look bad?

    Thanks,
    R

  • http://www.accepted.com Linda Abraham

    NKS,

    Look into UT, Rice, Kellogg, Michigan, and Duke.

    Best,
    Linda

  • http://www.accepted.com Linda Abraham

    Mike J,

    I usually recommend that you waive your right to see the recommendation. I think doing see will add to the credibility of the rec becasue the adcom knows you can never see it and that the recommender didn’t’ fear "repercussions" if he or she said something negative.

    Best,
    Linda

  • http://www.accepted.com Linda Abraham

    Rebecca,

    I think that HBS by asking for career vision is allowing you to be a little more general. And again I refer you to the parable of the stone masons linked to above.

    Regarding your second question, if your recommender provided specific examples of your strengths and competence in 170 words, you’re fine. It might have been nice if she had provided a second example, but quality trumps quantity.

    Best,
    Linda

  • nks

    thanks a ton…

  • jeff

    hi Linda,

    I am 31 years old and leading two countries (taiwan and singapore) for a pharmaceutical company, I have a master in pharmacy from an austrian university and have been living in asia for over 8 eight year now being, i am fluent in Mandarin, Japanese, German and English
    My GMAT score is only 630 (75% verbal 63% quant, 6.5 awa)
    what do you think are my chances to get into HBS?

  • Gaurav

    Hello Linda,

    I am 23/male and an Indian. I would like to know my chances of applying in top Ivy League University as I plan to enter Management domain after 2 years.

    1) 3.1 GPA from MS in Computer Science program at Columbia University
    2) 3.9 GPA from Under-Graduate Computer Science program from University of Mumbai
    3) Over 18 months of combined Internship Experience in India and US
    4) 2 Research Papers written at Columbia University in Security domain
    5) Strong recommendation letters from well-known professors

    I have joined a Security firm at present and looking forward to work for atleast 2 years. I plan to give GMAT sometime later in the year.

    Any tips/guidance to help improve my profile is welcome. Thank you.

  • Nagib

    Hi Linda

    Thank you for providing such excellent advice. It would be of great use if you could kindly do a quick evaluation of my chances at HBS.

    *Age: 25
    *Origin: Bangladeshi (6 years in UK)
    *Undergrad: 3.4 gpa Bsc Economics (University of Southampton, UK)
    *Masters: 3.6 gpa MSc Economic
    (London School of Economics, UK)
    *GMAT: 700
    *Work Experience:
    ^ 1 year at transaction services in Deloitte
    ^ 2 years as analyst in Goldman Sachs
    ^ Started Bangladesh’s second asset management company. Endorsed by Nobel Laureate Muhammed Yunus

    ^Economic Advisor for Microcredit expansion

    ^Director of MOER (free market think tank listed in the American Enterprise Institute)

    Thanking you

    Best

    Nagib

  • mp

    Hi Linda, Happy New Year!

    I was in the midst of writing my HBS essays until I stumbled upon this. Reading through all of your responses, I am becoming increasingly worried about my odds. Though not stellar, I would like to know your thoughts – whether you think I should go for it, hold off for a year, or outright forget about it.

    My profile:

    - 23 years old, graduated Columbia University Engineering 1 year early (at age of 20) with 3.1 GPA.I transferred after my first year from RPI to care for my ill grandfather.
    - completed 2 internships (1 with a hedge fund, the other with Merrill Lynch) as well as managing a family-owned business (50 people), all during the course of my undergrad experience.
    - GMAT 700 (50Q 93% V34 68%) – I acknowledge the low verbal here but would like your input as to whether it warrants a retake. It falled within the middle 50%, but I’m not sure that means much with below average GPA.
    - After graduating, I worked full-time in the Equity Research department at Merrill Lynch, and left a year later to work in a successful hedge fund (they recruit at HBS).
    - Extracurricular/Community: I began a P90X workout routine in my building’s basement that expanded to over 20 people; renting out a place now to attract more interested individuals. I was thinking to discuss this in the community or organization essay, do you think this experience warrants a feasible response, or is HBS looking explicitly for the non-profit organization answer?
    - I passed Level 2 of the CFA exam in June. This goes well with my plans of staying in finance and opening up my own venture. I was thinking to discuss this in the career vision essay, but not sure whether this essay is a meaningful read. Your thoughts?
    - Does my low GPA/GMAT combo warrant the additional essay? I worry it will come off as an excuse.

    Thank you for reading.

    Best,
    mp

  • mp

    Also, I am of Russian and Hispanic descent, though I was born in the US. My goals include leveraging my background and languages to expand my business globally – not sure if that needs to be included.

    In the previous post, I accidentally wrote "falled," my mistake – I meant "falls".

  • Yoske

    Dear Linda

    I would like to understand my changes at HBS.

    Female (26)
    Asian with 1 year global experience during college
    3 year work experience in global top 3 management consulting and top3 high-tech company with focus on strategic planning
    GMAT 720, Toefl 113
    and GPA 3.97/4.30 (Major in business)

    I think my weakness is not having impressive extracurricular activities or community service activities. I have some, but none of them are spectacular.

    What do you think? Thanks in advance.

  • Linda Abraham

    Jeff,

    I am sorry, but I think your chances at HBS are very poor. Your GMAT is low and you seem to be more experienced and older than the students HBS tends to admit.

    I encourage you to look at other programs friendlier to older applicants. You may also want to consider retaking the GMAT to improve your competitiveness.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Gaurav,

    Given that you aren’t applying for two years, I can’t assess your chances, but I can give you a few tips and point you to other resources.

    Tips:

    1) Make time for non-professional commitments so that you can show leadership skills.
    2) You are coming from a scientific/technical background. Great! Make sure that in performing your job you seize opportunities to develop business skills and experience.
    3) Try to add an international element to your work.
    4) visit the schools you are interested in while they are in session.

    Resources:
    BW had a series within the last year or two breaking down what you should do during the 5 years prior to application. It had excellent suggestions.
    http://www.accepted.com/mba/applicationwebinar.aspx .

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Nagib,

    You have a competitive profile for HBS.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Milan,

    I share your concerns about the academic aspects of your background. I would advise you to retake the GMAT and apply R1 of next year with a higher score and another year of work experience.

    At the same time, your Hispanic background and professional achievements are definite pluses.

    Regarding the questions you asked about the essays, it is very difficult to say without reading your entire set what should be included in a specific essay.

    Regarding the optional, you should inform the adcom of any extenuating circumstances that hurt your GPA so they can have context when they evaluate the application. Take responsibility, don’t whine, but do inform.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Yoske,

    Your academic are certainly excellent. Your work experience superficially is competitive,but it really matters what you did for your employers. Furthermore, candidates who can demonstrate impact and leadership off the job do have a better chance of acceptance.

    Best,
    Linda

  • DCR

    Linda,

    I’m finishing up my HBS application this week. I wanted to know your thoughts on my chances.

    Demographics: 26 white gay male with rust belt working class roots
    GPA: 3.8 in Middle Eastern studies from top 50 university
    GMAT: 740
    Career: 3.5 years as Arabic linguist for intelligence agency; served tours in Jordan and Iraq; promoted twice
    Leadership/Service: DC student coordinator for presidential campaign; English instructor for Sudanese refugee children during study abroad semester; Helped develop and implement HIV/AIDS education program for Malaysian college students; Founded sports league for LGBT young professionals; Tutor and mentor for local DC students touched by or afflicted with HIV/AIDS
    Potential Drawbacks: Because of job restrictions, cannot discuss in detail experiences on the job

  • abn

    Hello, I am hoping for feedback on my potential of getting into 3rd round of Harvard for 2010

    I am 30 years old
    Went to a top tier University GPA 2.7

    - worked at an internet start up out of college- tried to start my own wireless company (failed)
    - worked at fortune 500 in increasing levels
    - started my own iPhone application development company. Successfully developed 20 applications, opened an office in Boston with 5 employee, currently over 50,000 people use our software

    I have good recommendations but am weak on community service

  • abn

    forgot to mention GMAT 730

  • M Kumra

    Hello Linda
    I am an Architect with 8 years of corporate experience. I have a five years of bachelors and 2 years of Masters study background. due to financial reasons, I was not able to finish my masters though (from university of Cincinnati).

    I have keen interest in green building/energy/environment related issues and have certificates/accredition designated as LEED AP (Leadership in Energy, Environment and Design) from the US Green Building Council to formalize my enthusiasm in it.

    Apart from that, i have been building a network marketing business in which I have attained quite a significant level of financial success. I have built several teams and earned leadership of my team through effort and quality mentor-ship versus just a positional leadership. I have extensive experience in creating positive team/group dynamics.

    I want to join HBS to further my interest in the energy/environment sector and after graduation would want to join a company that deals with policy making and consulting in the same.

    I got gmat score of 610. Do you think HBS would be interested in my profile?

    Eagerly awaiting your input. Thank you for your time!
    M Kumar

  • Pranav22

    Dear Linda,
    Thanks for your wonderful responses. I read some of them, and hence am inspired to know about my own chances at HBS.

    My profile:
    I am an Indian male (age 26 yrs), working for India’s largest IT consultancy servcices, since 3.5 yrs.
    My GMAT score jumped from 680 to 760 over 2 attempts. My TOEFL score is 111.
    I graduated in Engineering from Mumbai University with decent acads (not spectacular) and good extra curriculars. In profession, I was promoted from a developer to designer to analyst in just 3.5 years, which is quite an achievement. However, I could not concentrate much on extra-curr in this period.

    Can you please tell me about my chances at HBS?

  • hbs applicant

    Hi Linda, Thanks for your blog.

    I’m a competitive applicant to HBS and I intend to apply in Round 2. My spouse has been accepted to the Harvard Kennedy School and will be matriculating in the fall. Is this something that I should mention in the Additional Information section of my application? Does it even matter?

    Thanks so much!

  • Linda Abraham

    DCR,

    You have a competitive profile for HBS.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    abn,

    I am not optimistic about your chances at HBS. I don’t think you are competitive. Your GPA is low and your community service is weak. In addition, you are several years older than most MBA students at HBS.

    If you want to apply to HBS, also apply to other programs. Specifically check out Babson and BU.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    M. Kumar,

    I am sorry, but I don’t think you would be a competitive applicant at HBS.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Pranav,

    If you can show a history of leadership and impact, then you have a chance at HBS. If not, I am pessimistic.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    hbs applicant.

    I think it is a good idea to mention it in the additional information section. it matters slightly because they will have greater confidence that you will attend if accepted. However, HBS doesn’t really worry about its yield so I don’t think it is a major factor.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Daljeet Singh

    Hi Linda,

    Hope you are doing good.

    I am male 24 India, I have a 3.0 GPA and 760 GMAT, Q – 83%ile / V – 99%ile, I have worked at a successful internet startup, was heading the sales & marketing at 22. Did some quantifiable work like increasing the sales by 500% & the user base by 300% etc.

    Apart from that I have advised two different internet startups in their marketing efforts and been on board ofboth of them as an advisor.

    I also volunteered for an NGO throughout high school and college and have substiantial ammount of leadership experience there as well.

    My question – is my GPA too low for HBS. Will my GMAT score be able to counter it. If I still apply in R3 how good are my chances. What else do you suggest.

  • Linda Abraham

    Is your GPA a translation of an Indian percentage score? If so, don’t use a translation unless asked.

    However a 3.0 from a US university would be an obstacle that could seriously hurt your application.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Daljeet Singh

    Hi Linda,

    The GPA is a translation actual percentage is around 70% a i.e. a first class degree. Also throughout college I was involved with the above mentioned NGO.

  • Manoj

    Hi Linda,

    First of all, I think it’s great that you take the time to help applicants in this forum. I look forward to your inputs on my chances at HBS.

    I am planning to apply to HBS for the session of 2011.
    I am male, 25, from India and my GPA in Mechanical Engineering is 9.2/ 10 from the Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi (IIT) which is one of the top Indian Engineering/Science institutions. I have been awarded scholarships during my entire student life. My GMAT score is 710 (99th Percentile in Quantitative, 69th Percentile in Verbal – AWA 4.0)
    I joined Unilever in India as a Business Leader Trainee (BLT) and have been working there since last 3 years. To share-BLTs in Unilever are inducted at par with MBA graduates and are offered similar growth opportunities and compensation. The BLTs are offered managerial roles very early in their careers. During my training period, I have worked across functions like Manufacturing, Sales & Operations and Supply Chain in various Indian locations (New Delhi, Mumbai, Calcutta, Chennai).
    However, in my current stint with Unilever, I am heading the production for one of their manufacturing plants. The role requires significant leadership as I have managerial responsibility here with 10 direct reports and 400 factory workmen. Though most of my exposure has been with the Indian offices, I have also been involved in a few international assignments in Unilever based out of UK, China, Singapore, Thailand.
    I have the following questions regarding my application to HBS and would like some guidance from you-
    1) Will my lower English percentile in GMAT and a 4.0 on the AWA hurt my application? (I want to share that English has been the medium of my entire education and is the working language at office as well)

    2) Is my GMAT score good enough for top US B-schools including HBS? Do you think I should retake my GMAT or should I go ahead with applications?

    3) If I retake my GMAT, would my highest score be considered?

    4) I have not been directly involved with any NGO or sports activities, however, the nature of my work involves immense people development focus like coaching my team pre/post appraisals and building a productive team environment. Also, I have been engaged in additional activities at my workplace other than my defined set of responsibilities like recruitment initiatives, sustainability initiatives etc. Please let me know if these will count while submitting my application to HBS?

    Do think I can take a shot at HBS next year with this profile? Please let me know your views.
    Thanks and regards,
    Manoj

  • Linda Abraham

    Daljeet.

    Do not translate unless the school requires you to do so, and if it requires you to translate, include somewhere information like class rank and first class.

    I don’t think your GPA is a problem for HBS, especially given your GMAT. I am concerned however about a R3 application, and I don’t advise it for you.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Anil Sharma

    Dear Linda,

    Please evaluate my profile:
    Work Experience: 3.5 years with Big Four Accounting/Advisory Firm.

    Started a division within my family business. Expanded the business to annual revenues of over $1MM and 22 full-time employees. The division serves as exclusive distributor for 6 US, UK and Spain based companies (and growing) in India and the Middle East. Including sustainable, eco-friendly building products.

    Industries Served: Energy, Oil/Gas, Public Sector Housing and Non-profit

    Major: Accounting / Information Management
    GPA: 3.34 Overall
    Major GPA: 3.60
    GMAT: 670 (49Q, 33V)

    Extra-curriculars:
    1) Big Brother (BBBS of America)

    2) Founded a entrepreneurial non-profit to help small businesses by providing creative services (photographing, brand management, marketing) in exchange for charitable donations to organizations of their choice. Created double-bottom line with over $15,000 in business savings and generated nearly $2,000 in donations. Grown from 1 to 37 members.

    3) President of Golf enthusiast Forum that organizes training clinics for young professionals. Provides a medium for networking, sharing golf tips and teaching others the game of golf.

    3) Co-chair of Comm. Service Planning Committee at work.

    4) Avid Golfer and Tennis Enthusiast

    5) Pursuing Private Pilot Training and Sailing Lessons.

    Long-term goal: Sustainable low-income housing in India, take the family business public (IPO) and continue doing ordinary things extra-ordinarily well.

    What do you think?

  • GP

    Dear Linda,

    I am going to apply to HBS this year. I am concerned about the age factor because I will be 32.

    However, my situation is different. I was originally from China. Because both my parents got cancer, I had to start working at 18 to financially support their treatments. I immigrated to the U.S. in 2002 to work in order to help my parents. From 1998 to 2007, I was working in the manufacturing field (mostly the semiconductor field) as a supply-chain management specialist and a senior business planner. Regardless of the fact that I didn’t have a chance to obtain an undergraduate degree, my dedication, sense of responsibility, and multi-cultural background convinced my employers that I was capable of leading. I have worked in only international companies (both large scale and start up companies) and gained experience in both Asia and the U.S.

    I finally went back to school full time in 2007, and I will complete my bachelor of liberal arts degree in 2010 at Harvard Extension. My GAP is over 3.8 with a major in Economics and citation in Government. I haven’t taken GMAT yet, but I will make sure to get the highest score possible. I also have strong recommendation letters from a few very raputable professors at Harvard (including one from HBS) and from my previous employers. Assuming that I can write good essays, do you believe that I will have a good chance of being accepted at HBS despite my age?

    I’m also going to apply for Sloan, Kellogg, Wharton, and Stanford. What do you think about my chances of gaining admissions in their MBA programs?

    Thank you!

    GP

  • FW

    Hi there Linda,

    Been keeping up with this blog for some time, thanks for the excellent advice.

    I’m 24 and have the following profile:

    - 3.65 from a top-tier Ivy in math, significant leadership
    - 3.9 from a one-year MS (technical)
    - 2 yrs IB experience at a top-tier bulge bracket bank
    - Am about to start at a tier 1 VC fund
    - 730 GMAT
    - Asian American male

    Wondering whether I should have a go at applying to bschool for c/o 2013 or c/o 2014? And on leadership/community post-college, I have very little given those of us in IB barely have time to sleep, any advice? Finally, would appreciate any assessment on my chances.

    Take care,

    FW

  • Linda Abraham

    Anil,

    I’m sorry, but I do not think you have a competitive profile for HBS. I think your academic stats are a problem in this highly competitive applicant pool.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    GP, assuming that you have a competitive GMAT, I think you have a chance of acceptance, but I don’t think it is a good one. Again assuming a competitive GMAT, your chances would be better at Stanford or Kellogg. You may also want to look into MIT, Tuck, Darden, or Purdue, especially if you want to stay in manufacturing.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    FW,

    Thanks for the feedback.

    You have a competitive profile for HBS and I encourage you to apply. If you think you are ready this fall, I see no reason for you to postpone your application an additional year.

    If your new job gives you a little time for an extracurricular commitment, grab it and start now. If not, make the most of what you did in college as well as new opportunities for leadership both on your new job and in professional associations.

    If you would like help with your application, please let me know.

    Best,
    Linda

  • DD

    Dear Linda,

    Thank you for this blog. Its extremely helpful.
    I contacted you previously on this blog about applying to HBS and Wharton in the 2nd round. I am now choosing a school to apply to in R3. I am worried that this round is very competitive so I wanted to know if I stand a chance.

    I am a 23 year old Egyptian female. I have been working in a local company for 2 years in marketing. Although I have had one high appraisal and a recent promotion to supervisor, my responsibilities have increased a lot.
    - Bsc. with Honors. Double major.in business and strategic mgmt 3.8 GPA. (equivalent converted from German system) from a top Egyptian university
    - Involved in community work
    - 720 on GMAT (48Q 83%/ 41V 92%)
    - Lived in different countries. Speak 5 languages (with diff levels of proficiency)

    I am selecting between five very different schools: CBS, LBS, Tuck, Johnson and Yale SOM. Is my profile competitive in any of these schools? If so, which one(s)? Do I have any chance of being accepted in R3?? Or should I wait until R1 next year? I would really appreciate your advice.

  • Manoj

    Hi Linda,

    First of all, I think it’s great that you take the time to help applicants in this forum. I look forward to your inputs on my chances at HBS.

    I am planning to apply to HBS for the session of 2011.
    I am male, 25, from India and my GPA in Mechanical Engineering is 9.2/ 10 from the Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi (IIT) which is one of the top Indian Engineering/Science institutions. My GMAT score is 710 (99 % Q, 69% V, AWA 4.0)
    I joined Unilever in India as a Business Leader Trainee (BLT) and have been working there since last 3 years. To share-BLTs in Unilever are inducted at par with MBA graduates and are offered similar growth opportunities and compensation. During my training period, I have worked across functions like Manufacturing, Sales & Operations and Supply Chain.In my current stint with Unilever, I am heading the production for one of their manufacturing plants and managing a team of 10 directly and 400 factory workmen.
    I have the following questions regarding my application to HBS and would like some guidance from you-
    1) Will my lower English percentile in GMAT and a 4.0 on the AWA hurt my application?

    2) Is my GMAT score good enough for top US B-schools including HBS? Do you think I should retake my GMAT or should I go ahead with applications?

    Do think I can take a shot at HBS next year with this profile? Please let me know your views.
    Thanks and regards,
    Manoj

  • GB

    Hi Linda,
    Thank you very much for taking time to reply to these inqueries. I find it very helpful that you are able to identify applicants weak areas and was hoping you can take a quick peak at my basic stats. I am 29.
    School and GMAT
    3.61 GPA Major in Business (3.89 GPA in core curric.), Minor in Chemistry, Valedictorian in High School (top nationally recognized school, multiple blue ribbons etc.) 710 GMAT (Q 45-74%, V 42-95%)
    Business
    6yrs experience
    Restructured a family business, after an embezzlement/sabotage effort of the previous president. I am currently president of the new company.
    Also worked through college, helped the owner change direction due to market changes.
    Extra
    Not much community type stuff, but I did compete in Judo in college on a national level, with some success (placing 4th in State Championships, 1st in a few Open Events, etc.)
    I did volunteer work ages ago, and provided tutoring services in college as well, but not sure if thats applicable today.

    I plan on applying to top level schools including HBS, Columbia, Stanford, Kellogg, Booth, Wharton, Stern, Berkeley. I realize its the third round for these schools, and I plan on reapplying next year if I am not accepted and will include some lower ranked schools such as McCombs and Univ. of Arizona. Do you think I should join some local community service org.? Thank you so much for your time. -GB

  • Linda Abraham

    DD,

    Because of the unusual nature of your profile and your high stats, you are one of those people for whom I do not think R3 will be as big an issue as for those with more common profiles or academic weaknesses. You have little to lose by applying R3 at the schools you are most interested in. If you don’t get in, reapply R1 next year. Of the schools you listed, I think your best bets are Columbia and Yale.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Manoj,

    To answer your questions:

    1) Possibly.
    2) You have the time to retake because you intend to apply R1 of next year. If you believe you can improve he verbal, I think the prudent thing to do is retake. Why gamble that it keeps you out if you think you can raise it.

    Yes, the information you provide is competitive at HBS. However, lack of community service is a weakness. If you can get involved with something now, do so.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    GB,

    Yes I think you should be able to show a commitment out side of work. It can be a community service organization or something else.

    Your plan is solid, but I would focus most of your energies on schools with higher average ages at matriculation.

    Best,
    Linda

  • dennis

    Hi Linda,

    I graduated with a 3.8 gpa in aerospace engineering from a tier I school. I am currently an officer in the Air Force and serve as a project manager for a multi-million dollar program. I take the GMAT in a month and have been scoring in the 680 range with on and off studying (feel I can score in the low 700 range). I am planning on applying to HBS in 2 years, which by then I will have 3.5 years of work experience. How do I far with my stats and if I fall short of 700, say 680, am I doomed? Does HBS have a quota veterans? Thanks a lot Linda. I look forward to your response!

    - Dennis

  • dennis

    Linda,

    Sorry, I forgot to mention a couple of stats. I will be 28 when I plan to apply. I plan on doing community service as soon as I knock the GMAT out.

    - Dennis

  • Linda Abraham

    Dennis,

    A 680 will defintely not doom you at HBS especially if you have a 3.8 in engineering from a tier one school. Obviously higher is better, but don’t drive yourself nuts.

    HBS does not have a quote for veterans to my knowledge. It values military experience and I haven’t heard about a glut of officers.

    Given that you are 28 and already are managing a major project, is there a reason you will not apply for another two years? Is that when you separate from the military? If you finish earlier, you may want to consider applying as soon as you finish your military obligation.

    Also, I highly recommend MBApodcaster’s episode on Military MBA’s for you.

    Best,
    Linda

  • dennis

    Linda,

    Thank you for the response. You are absolutely right. My service commitment is until 2012. I am almost 25 and will be applying when I am 27. My commitment ends about 1 month before HBS starts, so the timing might work out perfectly. Once again, thank you for your response!

  • DN

    Linda,

    Thank you for your help! I am 26 year old White Male, working for a big four accounting firm (Will have 1 year of experience when I apply in the fall). I graduated with a 3.64 GPA from a top accounting program (top three in most rankings). I also have a Masters in Accounting from the same school.

    I have had many leadership and service opportunities, including a two year church service mission to Mexico. I also ran a successful start-up while in school. With a 720 GMAT, how are my chances at HBS?

  • Linda Abraham

    DN,

    You have competitive profile for HBS and are applying appropriately.

    Best,
    Linda

  • AP

    Dear Linda,

    Thank you very much for your time.

    I’m considering whether to apply for MBA in Round III now or in Round I in the Fall. I’m wondering whether you can give me some advice or thoughts.

    As for my background, I am a 24 years-old Asian-American. I’m also 1/4 Hispanic ethnically (grandma from Paraguay), but I don’t think b-schools will really take that into account as URM, so I usually just classify myself as Asian-American.

    I got a 740 on my GMAT, I majored in Biochemistry and Politics, and got an overall GPA of 3.4 (3.9 in Politics, 2.9 in biochemistry) at a top-10 public university. I also did an exchange program in Korea and Japan to study biochemistry and politics, respectively.

    My professional backround is in environmental finance and climate change. I’ve been working two years in Asia and SE Asia (mainly Korea and China) in the carbon market as a carbon trader at a local medium-sized Asian firm. I am also managing a fuel-switch project in Africa and a palm oil project in Malaysia to reduce greenhouse gases and receive carbon credits approved by the United Nations.

    I also speak 3 foreign languages (Japanese, Chinese Mandarin, and Korean) although all of them at intermediate levels.

    Your initial thoughts on my application would be very helpful. Thank you.

  • Linda Abraham

    AP,

    The safe route is to wait until Round 1 of next year. However, you have excellent and distinctive experience which could possibly get you in R3. However if rejected, I think it will be harder for you to get in R1 in the Fall.

    Best,
    Linda

  • dennis

    Hi Linda,

    I made a previous post on 12 Feb 2010. I recently scored a 670 on the GMAT. I am a little bummed out because I scored around 700 on my practice tests. I am not sure if I can do much better. Do you think I will be competitive applying to HBS or any other top 10 school with my stats (GPA: 3.8 engineering from tier 1, Experience: Project Manager in Military)?

    Dennis

  • Linda Abraham

    Dennis,

    What was the percentile breakdown of your GMAT?

    Linda

  • Abhinav

    Hi Linda,

    I am trying to see if I have a shot at HBS. BTW this is wonderful work that you are doing.

    27yrs old
    UG (Accounting, Mgmt and Econ Minor) 3.75,
    Masters in Accounting: 3.7
    CPA,
    Two Years in a Big four Acct firm
    GMAT 700

    I am from very small/poor country in south east asia and have been involved in a project over there to revive a industry and help the farmers of my country. I am deeply involved with a company back home and have helped them to get where they are now.

    My concern is the lack of Extra activites in my life as I am real busy at my current job.

    Thank you so much for your help.

  • Linda Abraham

    Abhinav,

    yes you have a shot at HBS. How good a shot depends on the impact you can demonstrate in your work and the leadership you have demonstrated on and off the job. The lack of extra-curriculars is a problem because it is usually difficult to show a lot of leadership professionally when you are fairly junior. If you are an exception and can show a lot of leadership,then you would receive serious consideration at HBS.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Abhinav

    Thanks Linda.

    What do u think my chances are in the other top 15 schools. Do they also focus more on leadership. I am mostly interested in Tuck, Yale SOM, and Johnson.

    Thanks again.

  • Linda Abraham

    Your chances are better Yale SOM and Johnson than at Tuck and HBS. At the same time, all top bschools want to see leadership, impact, and initiative. If you can demonstrate those qualities and your country is not over-represented in the applicant pool, then you should have a decent chance of gaining acceptance to top tier schools.

    Best,
    Linda

  • vakwam

    What are my chances?

    age: 26
    race: Hispanic
    school: Top 20 business undergraduate BS in Finance, double minors in International finance / Management. GPA of 3.45.
    GMAT: 690
    work experience: 5 years in Asset Management. 3 yrs at JPMorgan Asset Management, 2 yrs at HSBC. I’m currently an AVP.
    additional info: I purchased RE right after college in the peak of the market. I almost lost my house and I’ve created a non-for-profit organization that helps people keep their home via loan modifications, loan work outs. In the last year, we’ve saved over 30 homes.

    I’m thinking of HBS, Columbia, Stanford, Chicago, Tuck

    What do you think?

  • Linda Abraham

    I think your chances are probably better at Columbia and Chicago,but you certainly have a competitive profile for all the programs you list. I’m assuming that your GMAT quant is above 80%.

    If you would like help with your applications, please keep Accepted in mind.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Tony

    Linda,
    Very excited to stumble on this blog. I am currently in the process of preparing my application for fall 2011. I have a year of experience at bulge bracket IB. I was layed off May 2009 and I currently work at another bulge bracket (not IB role but I value structured products on the banks B/S), a role I started August 2009.

    Would you recommend I get all my letters of recommendation from my previous employer? Reason I ask this is because it will be a bit uncomfortable getting from my current manager and besides I plan to apply R1 (which makes it the same amount of time I would’ve spent at both jobs).

    GMAT – 780
    GPA – 3.9
    Experience – Currently 1.8 years since graduation.

    Thank you,

    Tony

  • Linda Abraham

    Tony, ideally I would recommend one from your current job and one from the previous job. However, if you are uncomfortable asking for a rec from your current boss or someone who has supervised you in your current position, then two from the previous job will have to do.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Ralph

    Hey Linda, your attention and advice is a great asset to all of us who follow your blog, thanks.

    Age: 25
    Licensed Pharm.D (Class of ’08)
    retail pharmacy experience x 8yrs (’00–’08)
    Seeking: Dual degree, pharm. patent law/MBA
    LSAT: 170+
    GMAT: 750+ (100% verbal)

    Recommendations:
    1) president of my pharmacy school; accomplished entrepreneur
    2) dean of international relations at a highly ranked, prestigious boston medical school. Accomplished boston real estate giant and international entrepreneur, my mentor/advisor in business goals.
    3) Former executive VP of the major top-5 global pharmaceutical manufacturer I interned for. My mentor/advisor in professional goals.

    Founded start-up @ ’04 while student. Business provides comprehensive suite of services to international students from very high net worth families. Net income so far comfortably accommodates salary for me >2x greater than pharmacist salary. Services: procuring residences+vehicles, providing access to high quality medical/legal/financial/ air-travel/academic services. Services possible via 3rd party vendors we have cultivated strong relationships with. Marketing now conducted in multiple US cities, and >15 major cities in Latin America, Europe, Middle East and Asia.

    Sparse extracurricular list includes completion of a highly coveted internship position and executive/president position of a handful of student groups. Prestigious internship acceptance after grueling selection process. Company interned with was major pharmaceutical manufacturer, one of the top 5 around the globe. Worked with brand team for its leading product. 3-month internship requiring professional presentation before company executives; Performed with excellence, subsequently followed by job offer after graduation. Regarding student groups, they previously had poor attendance rates, so I used my rank to produce explosive growth in attendance. Developed and spearheaded initiative to establish agreements with student groups with similar interests and limited attendance; 4 clubs in the agreement, each with only 5-6 attendees on average. each week one of the clubs was chosen, and each of the other clubs brought their attendees to the chosen club. Increased attendance triggered inc. interest among other students, all clubs experienced attendance growth. I also negotiated with student government for budgets that were multiple times the size of budgets before I joined. Catering also helped. Increased funding+encouragement from myself and boards i appointed led to planning of weekly events.Unfortunately reverted to initial condition within 1 to 2 semesters of my leaving office, due to poor or lethargic leadership and breakdown of the pact.

    GPA: 3.3–3.4 (due to focus on business since ’04; many episodes of multiple-consecutive-nights without sleep in order to accomplish business goals. However, my transcript shows that many of the courses i received 4.0s in were those courses fellow students were deathly afraid of. I like overcoming challenges that overwhelm other students, and my transcript demonstrates this. The reason I chose to focus on my business rather than achieving a GPA representing my true abilities was because GPA does not impact ability to get job as a pharmacist, n I had no fear at any point of not passing a course. Now, however, i see the GPA could have helped me here.

    My questions are, would it be beneficial for me to retake courses to improve my GPA, or would retaking courses actually reflect poorly upon me?

    All things considered, am I a strong, decent, or weak candidate in applying to HBS?

    Thank you so much for taking the time to read this, and my sincere apologies at the excessive length.

  • Ralph

    Sorry to extend an already lengthy post but wanted to add:

    My business initially started when my first client, a fellow student, requested tutoring because of my reputation for academic excellence. When they experienced more than modest grade gains, they recommended me to their friends. I ended up tutoring students in very diverse areas of study–anywhere from medical sciences to various engineering disciplines, liberal arts, sociology, international relations, architecture, civil engineering, art, and every aspect of business. The vast majority of these students experienced substantially improved academic performance as a direct result of my tutoring. Business courses represented the bulk (>75%) of what i tutored for; I’ve helped students analyze hundreds of business cases (many published by HBS), construct business plans, conduct financial analysis, strategic management, supply chain management, basically everything. My clients’ respect for my knowledge has reached the point where they approach me for consultation/partnership in developing real business plans intended for implementation. These include medium to large scale ventures often with high start-up capital needs. One recent example of a business plan I independently researched and wrote is based on refining third generation biodiesel plants into a sustainable form of crude oil. I presented the plan to some of my clients to raise investment capital, and had little difficulty securing commitments for $90 million in start-up capital. I am curious if I should talk about these considerations in my application for two reasons:

    a) to demonstrate passion/competence for business (initially this phase of my business was to allow me to study and pursue my passion for business in a way that also generated income for me)

    b) My tutoring almost always enabled my clients to improve their grade performance from low-mid Bs to low-high As. Can i use this accomplishment (the fact that their As were a direct result of my instruction) as evidence that I am capable of those grades myself? Basically, as a way of reducing the impact my official, sub-par GPA has on the assessment of my application?

    Last thing, I know it is semi-off topic but would demonstration of leadership in civil rights political activism be received favorably?

    Thank you tremendously for any insight you can provide to me. I feel terrible that my posts are so much longer than everybody else’s, but I am very curious to get your take on my situation. Thank you so much.

  • CS

    Hi Linda,

    Thanks so much for the information. It has been very helpful. I am actually an entrepreneur whose liquidity has freed up over the last few months and am thinking of applying 3rd Round to H/W/S. I have submitted for W, and am ready for H/S but haven’t submitted. I just wanted to hear your views on whether which weaknesses would be most glaring in my resume (weak GPA?), or whether I should consider applying in 1st round for class of 2013 instead?

    Asian, 28 years old, (2 years military conscription), GPA:3.55, Physics, Princeton University. GMAT 720: Verbal 87% Quant 93%. Took a full government scholarship to Princeton, worked for the government for 9months, joined morgan stanley IB for 1 year, then left to run my own fund in the last 3 years. Regular volunteer in China to teach English to underprivileged workers.

    Any feedback will be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

  • Linda Abraham

    Ralph,

    Everything except your GPA says you are a strong candidate for HBS. If you had F’s on your transcript then you should consider retaking, especially if the new grade would replace (not be averaged with) the old. However, if you had a few C’s, I wouldn’t retake. I would provide a succinct explanation of both why you did what you did and yes, use both your grades in difficult classes, your test scores, and your success as a tutor to show you have what it takes to succeed in an academic environment. I would also emphasize that you intend to be fully committed to your studies this time around.

    I would say you are a decent candidate for HBS and the only way to see if they will overlook your undergrad GPA is to apply.

    HBS would be interested in leadership in almost any arena, including civil rights activism.

    Please keep Accepted in mind when you apply. You might need our help in keeping within those word limits. :-)

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    CS,

    Your GPA is NOT weak. It is competitive, as is the rest of your profile for HBS. For Harvard and Stanford I almost always recommend waiting until R1, but unless you come from a country that sends lots of applicants to HBS and Stanford, give it a try R3.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Kokou

    Hey Linda, Thank you for reading!! is 27( 28 by the time i start) too old to apply to HBS, Stanford, Wharton? I will only have 2 years of experience by the time I start. Should i wait an extra year and start at 29 instead?

  • Linda Abraham

    No. it is not too old for HBS, Stanford, and Wharton, but I wouldn’t wait if you feel ready.

    Best,
    Linda

  • NS

    Hi Linda,
    You are doing a great job. I’m very much impressed with your responses. It would be grateful if you could help me by predicting my chances of getting into HBS.

    My Profile:
    Age – 24
    Nationality – Indian
    CGPA – 6.9/10 (Engineering degree in Electronics and communication)
    Work Experience – 3 years of experience in India’s largest IT company. Worked for few of the leading US banks.

    I was good at ECs but haven’t done anything big that brought a huge difference, was leader of few of the associations in college. And have also volunteered in the young women’s association and did few small activities in my current organization.

    Planning to apply for fall 2012.

    What would be right time for me to take up GMAT and what are my chances of getting into HBS if my score would be 700+ in GMAT and 110+ in TOEFL. And also kindly let me know how I can make my profile much more competitive and acceptable one.

    Thanks in advance,
    NS

  • Pavitra

    hey linda

    I wish to apply for 2+2 HBS program in 2010. Im currently pursuing a 5 year integrated law program (B.A.B.L.(hons.) in India and will finish with First Class honors and in the top 5% of my class. However, my college does not provide a GPA and my average percentage is 66 %, which Im afraid will be a weak point on my application. I am also pursuing a Masters in Business Law course through distance education and i will complete the first year exams in july, after the applications for HBS are sent out. Im wondering how to word this on the application. I have a GRE score of 1450/1600 I have been interning with a corporate lawyer for over two years, and i also have a start-up partnership firm which originally started out as a way to make some extra cash but now has turned into a profitable firm for non-litigation services. I am an active member in the Rotary and have been instrumental in setting up the Moot Court Association in my college and organizing a National level competition. I have also won an international moot conducted by the International committee for the Red Cross, among others. I have co-authored two articles published in national journals. I would like to know what my chances are for the 2+2 program, and what points i should highlight in my essays.

    Thank you so much for you help.

    Pavitra

  • Linda Abraham

    NS,

    Thanks for the feedback. A 700+ GMAT is helpful, but it my no means guarantees you a spot at HBS. In fact, once you get it, it is almost irrelevant because there are so many others with it that other factors become more important, especially your leadership experience and impact in multiple arenas. If you can shot that, you have a shot at HBS. If you can’t, then your chances are poor. If you currently don’t have much leadership, you can try to assume responsibility now, but they look for a record of leadership not a sprint.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    NS,

    I hate to be discouraging, but I am not optimistic about your chances even if you got a GMAT at or above the HBS average. In terms of the right time to take the GMAT, the score is good for 5 years so if you apply in two you don’t to worry about it expiring. Take it no later than six months before you plan to apply to that you can retake if necessary without postponing your application. Other than that, take it when you will have the most time to prepare for it.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Linda Abraham

    Pavitra,

    Assuming that HBS will accept people to 2+2 with a masters, you have a competitive profile. (Please note that if you in your last year ie a senior, you are not eligible for 2+2; it is for college juniors. See http://www.hbs.edu/mba/faq/#2plus2).

    In your essays you will want to focus on diverse leadership experiences and how your participation and leadership has made difference. For more tips on responding to the 2+2 questions, please see http://accepted.squarespace.com/acceptedcom_blog/2010/4/9/hbs-22-2010-mba-application-questions-deadlines-tips.html .

    Best,
    Linda

  • Pavitra

    Thanks Linda,

    My masters in Business Law is a distance education program, and my main course is an undergraduate course of which i am in the 4th year, with one year left after the application process. I have however written to the admissions department in Harvard to clarify the point. I would also like to know if i can incorporate experiences from school in my essays. I have been the cultural secretary of my school, which involves handling of all extra-curricular activities. I have also been on the editorial board of my school magazine for two years. I feel this would show leadership over a period of time rather than just my undergraduate experience. I would also like to know if i can use these experiences to answer specific essay questions, such as "what have you learned from your mistake"? Once again, i would also like to clarify whether a 66% without a GPA will hamper my chances.

    Thank you for your feedback.

    Regards,
    Pavitra

  • Linda Abraham

    Checking with HBS directly is a good move.

    You can certainly talk about your extra-curricular activities in your essays. Obviously, what you actually say matters, but they usually provide good material.

    Regarding your 66%, HBS and all US schools know that India has a different grading system and know how to interpret it. In general First Class Honors is competitive and you should also let them know that you are in the top 5% of your class. That provides context.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Jenee

    Hi Linda,

    I’m planning on taking gmat in august of this year and i want to apply for fall 2011 mba program with HBS. I finished my UG in 2007 in India with 84%.I was the college topper and awarded best outgoing student of the department. I have participated in various elocution competitions and many cultural events in various colleges.I’ve a work experience of around 2 years in a MNC where i was awarded best budding employee of the year. Till then i’m working along with my father in our Import/Export company. I’m actively involved in serving at an orphanage in our home town and an active member in a few other NGOs.Do I have a shot in making it to HBS and what should be my minimal score in GMAT ? I’m currently taking a rigorous GMAT training program.

    Thanks,
    Jenee

  • Linda Abraham

    Jenee,

    Yes you have a shot at HBS. I don’t want to give you a minimal score. First, prepare for the GMAT and aim for the best score, not the minimum. Second, I can’t be sure there is a minimal score. There is no score high enough to ensure acceptance, and you could get a below average score and still be seriously considered or even accepted. Just go in and do the best you can.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Siddarth_83

    Hi Linda,

    My undergrad is from a top Canadian business school – I averaged 3.0/4.0 (failed 1 Finance course in 3rd year) during my undergrad. I attribute my low undergrad GPA to transitioning issues (moved from an entirely different educational, social, academic background [Saudi Arabia] to Canada).

    I was born in India, lived there for 11 years before moving to Saudi Arabia, where I spent another 7 years and then moved to Canada where I completed Grade 12, before starting university.

    My GMAT is 710 (wrote it last week) – so I’m hoping that makes up for my low undergrad GPA? I plan to use one of my essays to talk about my failure in the Finance course as that taught me a lot. Overall, I’m confident I can pull a very good story for MBA. I have exceptional references (current manager loves my work at a Fortune 20 tech firm). I also worked in various Fortune 500 companies (HP, Coke, Citigroup) during my undergraduate; as well as working part-time for 2 out of 4 years during my undergrad. I was the Founder of two clubs on campus.

    What are your thoughts about my chances for Round 1 @ HBS? I’m hoping I can leverage my international background, solid story, strong GMAT and exceptional references.

    Thank you in advance.

    Sid A.

  • Linda Abraham

    Sid,

    I hate to be discouraing, but I am not optimistic. Even if HBS overlooks the F, a 3.0 GPA and 700 GMAT is not a compelling academic profile for them. Yes, the will look at other factors, but these are two biggies. Give it a try, but don’t set your heart on it.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Beth

    Hi Linda,

    Firstly, thanks a lot for taking the time to answer queries on this forum. I have 2 general questions:

    1. Apart from the 4 essays, can I submit additional essay to explain (i) my GPA (ii) an internship I did in entirely different area.
    2. The third recommendation, is it good to get it from a work-colleague who has worked closely with you in professional as well as extra-curricular activities (or should all recos be supervisors?)

    Thanks!

  • AKS

    Hi Linda
    I plan to apply for HBS 2+2 PROGRAM.
    I am a prospective third year student at the IIT Kharagpur(best undergrad univ in India). I have a present CGPA of 8.65/10 (top 8% of the university), which I can very well increase to 8.85 by the end of third year i.e by the time I apply. I plan to give my GMAT exam in the Jan’11.
    Apart from having had an excellent academic performance(I have ranked under 100 All India in Talent Search Exams since grade 6th) since school days, I have held the post of Literary Secretary and hence responsible to the LLR hall of residence and the Technology Gymkhana(the largest Student related body of the institute). I have participated in many Case Study competitions (4 in number in the last 4 semesters) with commendable appreciation in 2 of them. Apart from this I have been an ardent reader of Goldratt books…I represent my hall of residence in cricket at the General Championships and have been a member of Gold and Silver winning Dramatics team in IIT Kharagpur.

    Please comment on my chances of making it to HBS and in what ways I can improve as one year is still ahead and I can take necesaary steps.

    Thanks

    Akshat

  • AKS

    Just to add to the above, I have also been active debater and elocutionist and have many awards in the same,
    Thanks

  • Linda Abraham

    AKS,

    You have a highly competitive profile for HBS 2+2. To enhance your chances at this highly competitive program, earn a high GMAT and assume leadership roles. Participation is good, but leadership is what HBS wants to see. You may also be interested in my tips for the 2+2 program at http://blog.accepted.com/acceptedcom_blog/2010/5/21/harvard-hbs-2011-mba-application-questions-deadlines-tips.html .

  • Patrick

    Linda,

    I have a 740 on the GMAT (83%Q 97%V). I majored in math in college and currently work in a highly quantitative field. I am certain I can improve my quant score with a retake. Do you think it’s worth it?

    On one hand the quant score may not matter because my application will illustrate my math skills. On the other hand, my math skills are one of my selling points on my application and a score in 83% may call that into question.

    Thanks.

  • Linda Abraham

    If your math grades are strong, I don’t recommend a retake at all.

    Spend your time and effort on other things.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Brian

    Hi Linda,

    I graduated college with a 3.9 GPA from an ivy league college with a degree in government. I then worked for three years at a top strategy consulting firm. I took the GMAT and scored a 730, but my breakdown is 96th percentile V, 79% Q. I was scoring better on practice tests but didn’t do so well on test day on the quant section. Will my lowish quant score be held against me, especially if I didn’t take many math classes in college or should I stick with my score?

  • Linda Abraham

    Brian,

    I still think you’re fine and should not retake, but what math classes did you take in college?

    Linda

  • Brian

    I did not take a ton in college. I took an introductory Calculus class as well as a statistics class.

  • Linda Abraham

    Brian,

    I think you’re fine and wouldn’t retake if I were you.

    Linda

  • Sagar

    Hi Linda.
    Please let me know my chances at HBS. Thanks in advance for reading this long post.

    Indian, Male, 28.
    Education:
    - B Tech Mechanical from not so known uni.
    - Flunked during 3rd year of Engg
    - GPA 3.5/4

    Past Experience:
    Asst Sales Manager- 1 yr @ HSBC (2006)
    - Acquired & managed relationships with HNI clients. Dealt with & managed accounts of over 30 CEOs, Directors, VPs.
    (Really a rich experience)

    Executive- 1 Yr @ Citigroup (2005)
    - Managed corporate salary accounts. Got one quick promotion

    Current Experience:
    Startup-Entrepreneur (Since 2007)
    - Run a hightech start up company (Team size 4, I’m Founder-CEO) in mobile software domain.
    (Starting up in India is not so easy)
    - Did (and still do) all work falling under all the designations from ‘Clerk’ to ‘CEO’, except software coding.
    (Got hands on experience of actually running the business. Lot of multitaking)
    - Got over 100 clients. One of the client was 3rd Commonwealth Youth Games (2008).
    - Company profitable & revenue growing @ 50% y-o-y.
    - Recently launched a mobile software, that is being used by people across the world

    Extracurricular:
    During Engg-
    - President of student club. Took the membership level from 200 to 650 in 1 yr.
    - Founder member of departmental student club
    - Various posts in annual gathering, mess management etc
    - Organised over 20 different events
    After Engg-
    - Co-authored a weekly article series for 52 weeks in city’s no.1 newspaper.
    - Founded & run alumni association of the alma-mater university. Membership of over 1000 alumni. Organized various networking activities.
    - Delivered 3 expert seminars to engg & mass communication PG students.

    Community service:
    - Played instrumental role in organizing & conducting career guidance programs. Counseled over 2400 engineering aspiring students (2000-04)

    Awards & special achievements:
    - Secured a patent for a mechanical jack. Solely authored the patent at the age of 19 & obtained it in 4 yrs.
    - Won 5 National level awards for various science projects. (4 are from IIT Bombay. Was team leader in all projects)
    - Secured 5th rank in an International machine design contest (@ IIT Bombay)
    - Won a state level & a uni level award for tech paper presentation.
    - Won 2 consolation national level prizes in Mobile phone Photography
    - Received a special appreciation letter from the Vice Chancellor of the uni for extraordinary achievements in tech competitions

    Why HBS:
    - Want to build up on my leadership skills so that I can scale up my startup to much bigger level
    - HBS will give me bigger platform & opportunities to leverage my innovation abilities
    - Focus on case studies will give me much near to actual experience of subtle things in managing business
    - Huge alumni network

    What I bring to table:
    - Startup experience (from India)
    - solid innovation track record
    - Serve back (track record of running alumni asso., counseling)

    My GMAT test score is 670. Assuming I get fantastic recos & have really good experience stories for the essays, what do you think are my chances for HBS?
    I really appreciate you patience in reading this unusually long post. THANK YOU VERY MUCH!

  • Janu

    Hey Linda,
    I’ve got strong ug as well as gmat scores. I initially had work experience of 18 months in an MNC where i was awarded best employee of the year.. But then due to personal reasons i had to quit my job for 9 months.. Then i did an internship at an exim agency and now i have my own firm.. I just want a word of advice on whether the gap that happened in my career might hinder my prospects at HBS. Please advise me on the same.. Thanks in advance.

    Janu

  • Linda Abraham

    Janu,

    A nine-month gap in your resume could raise doubts or questions in the admissions committee’s mind. The best way to handle it is to provide information about the personal reasons that caused you to leave the work force for 9 months.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Anubhav Singal

    Dear Linda,

    I am 24 years (male from India) of age having just completed my Masters of Science in Mechanical Engineering Design from University of Manchester, UK.

    I have just landed a job in a reputed German Company and over the next two years I will be working at various location all over the world including Germany, India and China.

    My academics are fairly average 70% and above and I wish to apply to HBS 2-3 years from now.
    I am so keen for HBS because the Co I am working for now has just started operations in India and I have the sole responsibility of bulding my own knowledge at its headquarters and other already established places first and then bring it to India and transfer the knowledge sucessfully.

    I would just like to know your opinion on what my chances look like?
    I am yet to appear for GMAT, but I thought a head start is not a bad idea.

    Do you think it’s too ealry for me to think about HBS?

    Thanks and Regards,

    Anubhav

  • Linda Abraham

    Abunhav,

    It’s not too early for you to think about HBS. It is too early for me to assess your chances of acceptance. And it’s always a mistake to think exclusively about HBS.

    Best,
    Linda

  • Anubhav Singal

    Dear Linda,

    Thanks for your response, you are right ofcourse about not thinking exclusively of HBS, I am looking into other top schools as well. Yes there are are a lot of "if’s" about my propspects as I have only just started working, hence, diffcult to really assess my chances but I do hope that things shape up well.

    I would love to keep you posted, if you have the time. Is there any other way to interact with you?

    Thanks again and warm regards,

    Anubhav

  • Linda Abraham

    I apologize for the tardy response. You can contact me via the form at http://www.accepted.com/services/generalinquiry.aspx .

    Best,
    Linda

  • Nic

    Hi Linda,

    Many thanks for your much resourceful & constructive advices. Amazing work. I'm in the process of applying for HBS MBA entering fall 2011. My details as follow:-
    1) Malaysian Chinese, female, 29
    2) CGPA 3.4, Applied Physics (National University of Malaysia)
    3) Work: 6yrs experiences.4yrs,in local metal stamping co.handling major market leader customer in automotive ind.,project engineer. current:steelcase Inc (top office furniture corp, US based comp),design engineer
    4) extra-curriculars:management comm of The philharmonic choir of M'sia. Physics&chemistry tutor of Open University of M'sia.Ambassador club comm member of current company.
    5)Planning to take GMAT at Sept.
    What are my chances of getting into HBS if my score would be 700+ in GMAT (considering my weak CGPA)? Am I too old to apply?
    Nic

  • Linda Abraham

    Nic,

    I am concerned that your age and level of experience will be a hurdle at HBS, even if you get a 700+ GMAT, which is competitive at HBS. However, there are other fine programs where your chances would be better and where your age and level of experience would not take away from your chances at all.

    Best,
    Linda

  • PG

    Hi Linda,

    I am 21 years old, and just completed my Undergraduate. I finished with a 3.99 for all four years of University in a bachelor of science. I also received the highest average in my program. My GMAT score is a 710/6.0, and I have had summer jobs between every year. I have substantial community service ECs (e.g. international volunteering, and long-term local volunteering), and athletic awards, etc. I have no long-term work experience however because I just graduated. Do I have a chance with Harvard?

  • Linda Abraham

    Harvard admitted no one without full-time worke experience last year (and I believe the year before) and 4 people with one year of full-time experience. It's highly unlikely Harvard would accept you for 2011 matriculation even if you worked from now until you matriculate.

    Work for a year or two and then your chances will improve. Please see http://www.hbs.edu/mba/admissions/blog.html and scroll down to More about the Class of 2012.

    Best,
    Linda