• Business School
    • Admissions Help
    • MBA Essay Tips
    • Executive MBA Essay Tips
    • MBA Admissions Calendar
    • Free Guides
    • Video Tips
    • Podcast
    • Selectivity Index
    • EMBA: The Ultimate Guide for Applicants
  • Medical School
    • Admissions Help
    • Med School Admissions 101
    • Secondary Essay Tips (by School)
    • Student Interviews
    • Free Guides
    • Video Tips
    • Podcast
    • Selectivity Index
  • Law School
    • Admissions Help
    • Law School Admissions 101
    • Selectivity Index
    • Free Guides
    • Podcast
    • Video Tips
  • Graduate School
    • Admissions Help
    • Grad School Admissions 101
    • Free Guides
    • Video Tips
    • Podcast
  • College
    • Admissions Help
    • Free Guides
    • Supplemental Essay Tips
    • Video Tips
    • Podcast
Accepted

1 (310) 815-9553

Blog HomePodcastContact Us

Accepted Admissions Blog

Everything you need to know to get Accepted

November 28, 2016

Reading Time: 2 minutes

How Business Schools Have Failed Business

Business school deans and educational thought leaders are doing a lot of soul-searching concerning the role and culpability of graduate business schools in the economic downturn.

  • Dean Robert Bruner of Darden on April 5 wrote on Twitter “Controversy over the role of B-schools in the crisis. Did they warn strongly enough about the risks of toxic assets? Probably not.”
  • Joel Podolny, formerly a professor at Harvard Business School and Stanford Graduate School of Business and previous dean of Yale’s School of Management, asks “Are Business Schools to Blame?” He critiques schools for 1) Dividing the “challenges of management and leadership in a dysfunctional way.” 2) Communicating the idea that applicants should “measure the MBA degree’s benefit in terms of the additional salary they can earn.” 3) Lacking contrition and failing to make changes in response to fallout from the crisis. My $.02: While #1 makes sense, I disagree with #2 and #3. Applicants should expect professional advancement from a professional degree and see if the degree will pay for itself. Basic business concept. It’s a little too early for the programs to make meaningful changes in response to a crisis that really blew up in September.
  • Steve Kerr, former Chief Learning Officer at Goldman Sachs and at GE, disagrees vehemently in “Don’t Blame the Business Schools.”
  • Henry Mintzburg blasts the business schools (as usual) in “America’s Monumental Failure of Management.”
  • Stefan Stern defends them in “Why MBA bashing is unfair” 
  • President of Thunderbird Dr. Ángel Cabrera has been vocal in saying the business schools are culpable.

Additionally, there are a slew of articles in the Harvard Business Review about the responsibility of MBA programs for the financial crisis.

I would like to highlight today’s excellent piece on The Wall St. Journal editorial page by Dr. Michael Jacobs of UNC’s Kenan Flagler School of Business entitled “How Business Schools Have Failed Business.”

His main points:

  1. Misaligned and dysfunctional incentive programs rewarded short-term gain instead of long-term value creation. Most business schools do not systematically address compensation systems.
  2. Corporate boards were “AWOL.” Schools don’t require courses in board structure, composition, and processes. Courses in “ethics” are not enough and are not the same as governance.
  3. The investment community failed to accurately evaluate risks. Jacobs argues that “as the gulf between the provider and the user of capital widens, the risks involved with selecting and monitoring the participants in the portfolio increase.”

Article by Linda Abraham / Harvard HBS, MBA Admissions, McGIll University, Rankings, Stanford GSB, UNC Kenan Flagler, UVA Darden, Yale SOM / Harvard Business School, leadership, twitter, Wall St. Journal

Get Accepted!

Choose your desired degree and then the service that best meets your needs.

Which program are you applying to?

What do you need help with?

Join the informed applicants who read Accepted's blog!

8 Popular Posts

1. 7 Simple Steps to Writing an Excellent Diversity Essay

2. How to Write About Your Research Interests

3. 4 Ways to Show How You’ll Contribute in the Future

4. When Will Medical Schools Give You an Answer?

5. How to Write a Goal Statement for Graduate School

6. Sample Essays from Admitted HBS Students

7. Writing Your Physician Assistant (PA) Personal Statement [Plus Sample Essay]

8. Acing the PsyD Interview: The 3-P Plan

Recent Posts

  • Wharton Executive MBA Class Profile: Class of 2022
  • How to Save 100’s of Hours Studying: Making a Medical School Schedule That Makes Sense
  • MBA Admissions: Application Advice for IT Applicants
  • Don’t Let an Increase in Applicants Derail Your Med School Dreams
  • Heads Up: Price Increase Ahead!
This Site is Featured on GMATClub

Home Page Services and Prices MBA Med School Law School Grad School College

About Us Press Room Contact Us Podcast Accepted Blog
Privacy Policy Website Terms of Use Disclaimer Client Terms of Service

Accepted 1171 S. Robertson Blvd. #140 Los Angeles CA 90035 +1 (310) 815-9553
© 2021 Accepted

BBB A+ RatingStamp of AIGAC Excellence

Copyright © 2021 · Education Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in