Columbia 2007 MBA Application
Columbia's 2007 application is now available at the CBS web site. The essay questions are the same as last year's, and my advice hasn't changed either.
A couple of general comments first.
- First take a few minutes to strategize about the application as a whole. You want a balance of professional and non-professional experiences in the application.
- CBS (and every other school ) is first and foremost looking for answers to the questions posed. Yes they want to see how you will fit in the program through your essays, but make sure you answer the individual questions while presenting a comprehensive and impressive picture of you. Just today I was reviewing an essay, and it completely failed to answer the question posed. The question asked for "a time" in other words, an example or situation. The writer gave a survey. In my opinion he missed the boat entirely.
For the January 2007 Accelerated program, applicants can submit anytime between now and October 11, 2006. For Early Decision September 2007 matriculation, applicants can submit between August 16, 2006 and October 11, 2006. For Regular Decision 2007 matriculation, domestic applicants must submit before April 18, 2007 and international applicants must submit before March 1, 2007.
The Columbia 2007 MBA Application Essay Questions (My comments are in red)
Essays
The following essay questions are part of the 2007 application to Columbia Business School. In addition to learning about your professional aspirations, the Admissions Committee hopes to gain an understanding of your interests, values and motivations through these essays. How you answer these essays is at your discretion, there are no right answers and we encourage you to answer each question thoughtfully and honestly. Each essay should be typed and double-spaced on separate 8 1/2 x 11 paper with your name and the date of the final draft at the top of each page.
Essays:
1. What are your short-term and long-term post-MBA goals? How will Columbia Business School help you
achieve these goals? (recommended 750 word limit)
This is a very forward looking goals question. While you shouldn't ignore the factors that contributed to the development of your goals, the bulk of the essay should be about the future. What do you want to do immediately after completing your MBA? 5 years later? How will Columbia's program help you achieve your goals? And be specific!
2. What has been the greatest challenge to your value system that you’ve faced and how did you handle it?
(recommended 500 word limit)
Where were your values challenged and how did you handle it? This is a very broad question and you can use a professional or non-professional experience to answer it. Realize that the best answers are somewhat nuanced. They are thoughtful, not dogmatic or self-righteous. The situation doesn't to have to be an ethical dilemma where you have a clash of values. A situation where you were pressured to go against values you hold dear would be perfect for this essay. Clearly ethics and values are at the heart of this question.
3. In discussing Columbia Business School, Dean R. Glenn Hubbard remarked, “We have established the mindset
that entrepreneurship is about everything you do.” Please discuss a time in your own life when you have
identified and captured an opportunity. (recommended 500 word limit)
When have you taken a risk, assumed responsibility, and initiated a project in order to seize the moment and an opportunity? Again, this question could be answered from professional, college, or extra-curricular activities to maintain the balance I talked about above
4. Please select and answer one of the following essay questions. (recommended 250 word limit)
a. Please tell us what you feel most passionate about in life.
b. If you were given a free day and could spend it anywhere, in any way you choose, what would you do?
Either option is an attempt to get to know you as a human being, and they are both asking for the same thing -- just giving you different vehicles to present it. These options are both best answered with non-professional answers. Have a little fun with these questions and as always be authentic. There are no right or wrong answers; just demonstrate your enthusiasm for whatever you choose and include the reasons why you are so passionate about your topic. Finally, if you say you are so passionate about Subject X, make sure Subject X is an active part of your life, something you devote time to. Writing checks or having strong feelings won't do it.
5. (Optional) Is there any further information that you wish to provide to the Admissions Committee?
(Please use this space to provide an explanation of any areas of concern in your academic record
or your personal history.)
Obviously you could use this question to address a weakness in your application, but in my mind, it is also open-ended enough to allow you to discuss a diversity element in your personal background or simply some unique area of interest in your personal background. Also, tucking a weakness explanation somewhere else would allow you to end the application with a strength and not a weakness.
If you would like help with your Columbia MBA application, please consider Accepted.com's MBA essay editing and admissions consulting or a Columbia Comprehensive Package, which includes essay editing, interview coaching, consultation, and a resume edit for the Columbia MBA application.
Columbia has posted a new version of question two above in the online version of its application. The new question is:
2. Leading in the global economy requires enabling high performance from a diverse set of employees, colleagues and partners. Tell us about a manager you’ve observed who enabled or inspired others to do their best work and analyze how this manager did it. (Recommended 500 word limit).
A few elements in this question that would be great to include in your essay: It is a question about leadership of peers and employees. You should be able to provide examples of the manager you choose to cite inspiring both peers and subordinates, preferably from different backgrounds and perhaps with different interests. Then choose 1-3 elements that made that person successful and analyze them.
Although this question does not ask about you, if you can use this essay to highlight a project or responsibility not discussed in depth in another essay, you will be leveraging this essay question -- providing you also answer it directly and well.
On the BW Forum, CBS clarified that those who are using the first version of #2 do not have to switch. Columbia will accept either version. Certainly as long as the old version is in the PDF version of the application available on the web site, choose the question that you will feel will help you present yourself most effectively.
If you have a good example of a challenge to your value system, for most of you the better question to answer will be the old version of #2, since it asks you to talk about what you have done and how you handled a particular situation.
Thanks to ClearAdmit for pointing out the change.
I doubled checked the word limits on the Columbia September 2007 essay questions with Columbia's admissions office on Friday and here they are:
The Columbia 2008 essay questions, deadlines and tips are available now. We are closing comments on this article. If you have questions about Coumbia's application, please post a comment to the Columbia 2008 application article or a question in MBA Admissions Forum.

Reader Comments (200)
Thank you very much!!
Also, the word limit for question 1 has been changed back to 1000 instead of 750.
Ah.............. hope this is the last change
Thank you very much.
Can anyone tell me if I have the option of choosing the #2 essay -- between ethics and the new one on 'model manager'.
I started my online apps a week back and only the 'model manager' topic is showing up as essay #2. This is very confusing!!!
Per the update above, you can choose to answer the original #2.
For the 4th question, my current essay is at 350 words, can you please let me know if I really need to cut this down to 250?
Thanks!
Michael
Our rule of thumb is up to 10% over. The readers don't count words, but they will definitely realize if an essay is 40% over the limit. Unless the essay is an outstanding Wow! of an essay and you have cut every bit of fat and flab from it, you should cut it down. Please see http://www.accepted.com/newsletter/2005/0805news.aspx#essay for tips on cutting it.
Continuing on the GMAT score thought. The 10%-90% range for Columbia for 2005 was 660-750 with an average score of 706. Obviously you would like to have a score above the average, but how does a score like 680 appear to the adcom? It is in the range, however, on the lower end. Coming from a non-traditional Biomed Engineering ugrad background, how does it come off to the committee and should I consider taking the exam again in another month? Sorry for the long question. Thank you
-Muk
It can't be viewed in isolation, and a 680, even at a school like CBS that has a high average GMAT is certainly not a bad score. Was your score balanced or skewed? IF skewed, can you provide other evidence of skill in the area that was lower? Was your undergraduate record strong or was it a little lower than average for Columbia? Are you from a group that is under-represented or over-represented in the applicant pool? Does your work experience demonstrate exceptional, ordinary, or a little lower than average achievement and professional progression.
I'm sorry this is not the straight-forward answer you were probably hoping for, but it is the real one.
I'll respond to your question about retaking if you respond to my questions above.
Good luck!
Continuing on Muk's comment on the GMAT score, I also got a 680. I have a 3.7 GPA, and I'm an Asian, female officer in the Navy and I have been working on big construction projects. Does the adcom view the GMAT as the #1 indication of academic prowess, or do they balance everything? Thank you.